The Times Australia
The Times World News

.

Why taxing US billionaires’ wealth – as Biden tried to do – will never work

  • Written by Beverly Moran, Professor Emerita of Law, Vanderbilt University
Why taxing US billionaires’ wealth – as Biden tried to do – will never work

The speed with which a tax on billionaires came and went[1] as a means to pay for President Joe Biden’s economic agenda shows why it’s so hard to tax wealth in the U.S.

Democrats unveiled their proposal[2] on Oct. 27, 2021, and it was nixed that same day, replaced with a surcharge on millionaire incomes[3].

The idea of taxing the richest Americans’ fortunes has been batted around for some time, and perhaps with good reason from a tax perspective. The total wealth of U.S. billionaires soared by US$1.8 trillion during the COVID-19 pandemic[4] as of mid-August. And recent reporting has found that despite their massive riches, billionaires tend to pay very little in taxes[5].

As an expert on tax policy[6], I have observed that there’s a big obstacle standing in the way of a wealth tax: the Constitution.

Income and wealth inequality

Concerns about inequality have increased in recent decades.

Americans enjoyed substantial economic growth[7] and broadly shared prosperity from the end of World War II into the 1970s.

But in the 1980s, President Ronald Reagan dramatically slashed taxes on the wealthy[8] – twice – cutting the top rate on wages from 70% to 28%.

Studies have shown lower income and corporate tax rates, combined with other “trickle-down” policies such as deregulation, have led to steadily rising income for the richest Americans and wealth inequality[9].

The most affluent 1% controlled 39%[10] of all wealth[11] – including all cash, real estate, stocks, bonds and other investments – in 2016, up from less than 30% in 1989. At the same time, the bottom 90% held less than a quarter of America’s wealth, compared with more than a third in 1989.

Currently, the federal government taxes all income above $518,400[12] at 37% for single filers, with an additional 3.8% investment tax[13] on incomes over $200,000. Of course, as a ProPublica cache of tax documents shows, loopholes and tax dodges result in actual income tax rates being[14] significantly lower.

The problem with taxing wealth

Unlike an income tax, a wealth tax reaches the root[15] of both wealth and income inequality.

But there are strong[16] arguments[17] that a federal wealth tax is unconstitutional[18]. Wealth taxes violate Article I, Section 2, Clause 3 of the U.S. Constitution, which forbids the federal government from assessing “direct taxes” that aren’t apportioned equally among the states[19].

A direct tax is a tax on a thing[20], like property or income. An indirect tax is a tax on a transaction: for example, a sale or a gift.

The income tax is a direct tax and constitutional because of the 16th Amendment[21], which specifically allows income taxes without apportionment. As for property, you may notice that only states and cities levy real estate taxes[22]. In almost every case, the federal government cannot tax real estate or any other form of wealth absent a transaction.

Proponents of a wealth tax, such as U.S. Sen. Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts, cite a small group[23] of law professors who back her claim that a wealth tax passes constitutional muster. But the argument against constitutionality is strong enough that a Supreme Court challenge is sure to follow any attempt to enact a wealth tax[24].

Barring a victory before the conservative-leaning Supreme Court or an arduous amendment to the Constitution[25], the federal government is shut out of taxing wealth.

A rising tide

I agree with progressive lawmakers that the United States should return to economic policies that seek to lift all boats[26].

Although American wealth and productivity have surged in the past 40 years, most Americans have not seen their lot improve nearly as much[27] as the richest have[28] – and are paying higher tax rates[29]. In 2020 alone, America’s billionaires saw their wealth increase $560 billion[30], even as tens of millions were unemployed[31] or depended on food donations[32] to get enough to eat.

The U.S. tax system is at least partly responsible for these gaps. While a wealth tax may not be a workable solution, there are other means, such as higher income tax rates for the well-to-do or a wealth transfer tax[33] that focuses on the transfer of wealth to a billionaire’s heirs. These approaches could not only help solve the problem of inequality but would pass legal muster too.

This is an updated version of an article published[34] on June 9, 2021.

References

  1. ^ came and went (www.axios.com)
  2. ^ unveiled their proposal (www.axios.com)
  3. ^ replaced with a surcharge on millionaire incomes (www.nytimes.com)
  4. ^ soared by US$1.8 trillion during the COVID-19 pandemic (ips-dc.org)
  5. ^ billionaires tend to pay very little in taxes (www.propublica.org)
  6. ^ expert on tax policy (papers.ssrn.com)
  7. ^ enjoyed substantial economic growth (www.cbpp.org)
  8. ^ President Ronald Reagan dramatically slashed taxes on the wealthy (www.brookings.edu)
  9. ^ have led to steadily rising income for the richest Americans and wealth inequality (www.thebalance.com)
  10. ^ controlled 39% (www.cbpp.org)
  11. ^ wealth (www.m1finance.com)
  12. ^ taxes all income above $518,400 (www.nerdwallet.com)
  13. ^ an additional 3.8% investment tax (www.thebalance.com)
  14. ^ result in actual income tax rates being (www.propublica.org)
  15. ^ reaches the root (theweek.com)
  16. ^ strong (taxfoundation.org)
  17. ^ arguments (nymag.com)
  18. ^ unconstitutional (theconversation.com)
  19. ^ apportioned equally among the states (constitutingamerica.org)
  20. ^ is a tax on a thing (www.salon.com)
  21. ^ because of the 16th Amendment (www.law.cornell.edu)
  22. ^ only states and cities levy real estate taxes (www.financialsamurai.com)
  23. ^ cite a small group (www.bloomberg.com)
  24. ^ is sure to follow any attempt to enact a wealth tax (minnlawyer.com)
  25. ^ an arduous amendment to the Constitution (www.archives.gov)
  26. ^ seek to lift all boats (www.economist.com)
  27. ^ have not seen their lot improve nearly as much (www.latimes.com)
  28. ^ richest have (inequality.org)
  29. ^ are paying higher tax rates (www.propublica.org)
  30. ^ America’s billionaires saw their wealth increase $560 billion (www.forbes.com)
  31. ^ were unemployed (www.bls.gov)
  32. ^ depended on food donations (philanthropynewsdigest.org)
  33. ^ wealth transfer tax (www.taxpolicycenter.org)
  34. ^ article published (theconversation.com)

Read more https://theconversation.com/why-taxing-us-billionaires-wealth-as-biden-tried-to-do-will-never-work-170907

Times Magazine

Building an AI-First Culture in Your Company

AI isn't just something to think about anymore - it's becoming part of how we live and work, whether we like it or not. At the office, it definitely helps us move faster. But here's the thing: just using tools like ChatGPT or plugging AI into your wo...

Data Management Isn't Just About Tech—Here’s Why It’s a Human Problem Too

Photo by Kevin Kuby Manuel O. Diaz Jr.We live in a world drowning in data. Every click, swipe, medical scan, and financial transaction generates information, so much that managing it all has become one of the biggest challenges of our digital age. Bu...

Headless CMS in Digital Twins and 3D Product Experiences

Image by freepik As the metaverse becomes more advanced and accessible, it's clear that multiple sectors will use digital twins and 3D product experiences to visualize, connect, and streamline efforts better. A digital twin is a virtual replica of ...

The Decline of Hyper-Casual: How Mid-Core Mobile Games Took Over in 2025

In recent years, the mobile gaming landscape has undergone a significant transformation, with mid-core mobile games emerging as the dominant force in app stores by 2025. This shift is underpinned by changing user habits and evolving monetization tr...

Understanding ITIL 4 and PRINCE2 Project Management Synergy

Key Highlights ITIL 4 focuses on IT service management, emphasising continual improvement and value creation through modern digital transformation approaches. PRINCE2 project management supports systematic planning and execution of projects wit...

What AI Adoption Means for the Future of Workplace Risk Management

Image by freepik As industrial operations become more complex and fast-paced, the risks faced by workers and employers alike continue to grow. Traditional safety models—reliant on manual oversight, reactive investigations, and standardised checklist...

The Times Features

What Is the Dreamtime? Understanding Aboriginal Creation Stories Through Art

Aboriginal culture is built on the deep and important meaning of Dreamtime, which links beliefs and history with the elements that make life. It’s not just myths; the Dreamtime i...

How Short-Term Lenders Offer Long-Lasting Benefits in Australia

In the world of personal and business finance, short-term lenders are often viewed as temporary fixes—quick solutions for urgent cash needs. However, in Australia, short-term len...

Why School Breaks Are the Perfect Time to Build Real Game Skills

School holidays provide uninterrupted time to focus on individual skill development Players often return sharper and more confident after structured break-time training Holid...

Why This Elegant Diamond Cut Is Becoming the First Choice for Modern Proposals

Personalised engagement styles are replacing one-size-fits-all traditions A rising diamond cut offers timeless elegance with a softer aesthetic Its flexible design wo...

Is sleeping a lot actually bad for your health? A sleep scientist explains

We’re constantly being reminded by news articles and social media posts that we should be getting more sleep. You probably don’t need to hear it again – not sleeping enough i...

Ricoh Launches IM C401F A4 Colour MFP to Boost Speed and Security in Hybrid Workplaces

Ricoh, a leading provider of smart workplace technology, today launched the RICOH IM C401F, an enterprise-grade A4 colour desktop multifunction printer (MFP) designed for Austral...