The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
The Times Real Estate

.

Puerto Rico has a once-in-a-lifetime chance to build a clean energy grid – but FEMA plans to spend $9.4 billion on fossil fuel infrastructure instead

  • Written by Patrick Parenteau, Professor of Law, Vermont Law School
Puerto Rico has a once-in-a-lifetime chance to build a clean energy grid – but FEMA plans to spend $9.4 billion on fossil fuel infrastructure instead

The Biden Administration has a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to help Puerto Rico transition to a greener and more resilient energy future, but it’s on the verge of making a multibillion-dollar mistake.

Since Hurricane Maria devastated Puerto Rico in 2017, many residents and environmental advocates have called for new clean energy sources for the island. Currently Puerto Rico gets more than 97% of its electricity from imported fossil fuel[1]. Power is expensive[2] and unreliable[3].

Puerto Rico adopted laws[4] that called for generating 15% of its electricity from renewable sources by 2020, 40% by 2025, 60% by 2040 and 100% by 2050. But the Federal Emergency Management Agency, which controls relief funding for the island, appears ready to underwrite a rebuild of the old fossil fuel system.

As environmental lawyers[5] and professors of law[6], we are surprised to see FEMA move forward on a path that runs directly counter to the White House’s energy and climate policy. President Joe Biden has called for a governmentwide approach that promotes clean energy, protects public health and the environment, and advances environmental justice[7].

In our view, FEMA’s actions don’t support those goals. They also ignore legal requirements for federal agencies to carefully weigh the environmental impacts of major actions.

Power poles lying across a flooded ditch.
Power lines toppled by Hurricane Maria in Alta Vega, Puerto Rico, Sept. 30, 2017. Hector Retamal/AFP via Getty Images)[8]

Rebuild or replace with a more resilient green system?

In September 2017, Hurricane Maria[9] struck Puerto Rico with sustained winds of 155 mph. It tore a diagonal 100-mile swath across the island, demolishing tens of thousands of homes and washing away roads and bridges.

The storm toppled transmission and cell towers, snapped concrete power poles, battered power plants and plunged the island into darkness. It killed an estimated 3,000 people[10] and caused over US$90 billion in damages[11].

In response, Congress authorized some $23 billion in disaster aid[12], including at least $10 billion to restore or replace Puerto Rico’s electricity grid. It also passed the Disaster Recovery Reform Act[13] to promote a more flexible energy system that could withstand and recover quickly from climate disruptions.

FEMA, which administers the funds, has allocated $9.4 billion for rebuilding Puerto Rico’s electricity system and will start approving projects after it receives more details explaining how the work will be performed[14]. So far, none of this money has been earmarked for renewable power, except for a small sum to repair a hydroelectric dam that provides less than 1% of the island’s power.

The organizations making decisions in Puerto Rico are the Commonwealth’s Electric Power Authority[15], known as PREPA, and Luma Energy[16], a private company that received a 15-year contract in 2021 to manage power transmission and distribution on the island. PREPA and Luma have proposed hundreds of projects[17] for the coming decade, but none include federal funding for rooftop solar, community solar, battery storage or microgrids. Advocates say that this kind of small-scale local generation would make the island’s electricity cheaper, cleaner and more reliable[18].

A 2015 study by the nonprofit Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis[19] found that investing in solar and wind power and energy efficiency could transform Puerto Rico’s electrical system into a resilient grid[20]. And in 2020, the U.S. National Renewable Energy Laboratory estimated that rooftop solar power in Puerto Rico could generate roughly four times as much electricity as residents currently use[21].

Federal law requires weighing the options

Spending almost $10 billion to rewire an island with 3 million residents is clearly a major federal action with significant environmental impacts. Under the National Environmental Policy Act, agencies undertaking such actions must prepare an environmental impact statement[22] that takes a hard look at alternatives and invites meaningful public input.

PREPA and Luma’s proposed plan[23] includes reconstructing and hardening nearly all of Puerto Rico’s transmission lines and building at least two new natural gas-fired power plants. Burning more natural gas will affect air and water quality[24] and contribute to climate change. Natural gas is shipped to Puerto Rico in liquid form, so using more of it also means expanding import facilities and pipelines[25].

Instead of producing a full-scale environmental impact statement, FEMA produced a superficial programmatic environmental assessment[26] – a narrower study that did not weigh other options. It concluded that there would be “no significant impact[27]” from rebuilding Puerto Rico’s fossil fuel-based energy system. The study did not mention climate change, which scientists widely agree is making hurricanes larger and more destructive[28].

Earthquakes have rattled Puerto Rico’s aging centralized electricity system, worsening its power woes.

Beyond a pro forma invitation for public comment, FEMA made no effort to engage with overburdened communities of color that have disproportionately suffered from pollution and climate change[29] under Puerto Rico’s energy system. This directly contradicts Biden’s order to place environmental justice at the center[30] of federal energy and climate policy.

The National Environmental Policy Act also requires agencies to “study, develop and describe appropriate alternatives to recommended courses of action[31].” FEMA’s environmental assessment only considers rebuilding and hardening the existing grid, and does not mention renewable energy. When some public commenters criticized this omission[32], FEMA responded that it was not responsible for considering alternative means of generating electricity.

Advancing the public interest

Both PREPA and Luma are proponents of an energy strategy that centers on importing natural gas[33]. Federal law requires FEMA to take a broader approach and ensure that it spends federal money in ways that support U.S. environmental goals.

[Over 110,000 readers rely on The Conversation’s newsletter to understand the world. Sign up today[34].]

Courts have held that environmental justice is not simply a box to be checked[35]. In our view, the law clearly requires FEMA to give Puerto Ricans – who have lived with a creaky power system for four years – a seat at the table before it starts writing checks for projects that affect their lives.

References

  1. ^ more than 97% of its electricity from imported fossil fuel (www.eia.gov)
  2. ^ expensive (www.theweeklyjournal.com)
  3. ^ unreliable (www.washingtonpost.com)
  4. ^ adopted laws (www.utilitydive.com)
  5. ^ environmental lawyers (www.researchgate.net)
  6. ^ professors of law (www.linkedin.com)
  7. ^ advances environmental justice (www.federalregister.gov)
  8. ^ Hector Retamal/AFP via Getty Images) (www.gettyimages.com)
  9. ^ Hurricane Maria (www.nhc.noaa.gov)
  10. ^ killed an estimated 3,000 people (www.nytimes.com)
  11. ^ over US$90 billion in damages (www.nhc.noaa.gov)
  12. ^ some $23 billion in disaster aid (www.congress.gov)
  13. ^ Disaster Recovery Reform Act (www.fema.gov)
  14. ^ receives more details explaining how the work will be performed (www.fema.gov)
  15. ^ Electric Power Authority (aeepr.com)
  16. ^ Luma Energy (lumapr.com)
  17. ^ hundreds of projects (energia.pr.gov)
  18. ^ cheaper, cleaner and more reliable (cleantechnica.com)
  19. ^ Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis (ieefa.org)
  20. ^ resilient grid (ieefa.org)
  21. ^ four times as much electricity as residents currently use (www.nrel.gov)
  22. ^ prepare an environmental impact statement (www.epa.gov)
  23. ^ proposed plan (energia.pr.gov)
  24. ^ will affect air and water quality (www.epa.gov)
  25. ^ expanding import facilities and pipelines (theintercept.com)
  26. ^ programmatic environmental assessment (www.fema.gov)
  27. ^ no significant impact (www.fema.gov)
  28. ^ making hurricanes larger and more destructive (www.ipcc.ch)
  29. ^ disproportionately suffered from pollution and climate change (theconversation.com)
  30. ^ place environmental justice at the center (www.whitehouse.gov)
  31. ^ study, develop and describe appropriate alternatives to recommended courses of action (www.law.cornell.edu)
  32. ^ criticized this omission (www.fema.gov)
  33. ^ centers on importing natural gas (spectrum.ieee.org)
  34. ^ Sign up today (theconversation.com)
  35. ^ not simply a box to be checked (law.justia.com)

Read more https://theconversation.com/puerto-rico-has-a-once-in-a-lifetime-chance-to-build-a-clean-energy-grid-but-fema-plans-to-spend-9-4-billion-on-fossil-fuel-infrastructure-instead-169124

The Times Features

Seamless Kitchen Sink Installation: Achieving a Perfect Fit

A seamless installation needs to be well-planned. Site, material, and process all go into the final outcome. Installing a new piece or replacing a very old piece, exactness is ...

Studies of Parkinson’s disease have long overlooked Pacific populations – our work shows why that must change

A form of Parkinson’s disease caused by mutations in a gene known as PINK1 has long been labelled rare. But our research[1] shows it’s anything but – at least for some popula...

A Simple Guide to Assembling a Home Electrical Toolkit

Having a well-equipped home electrical toolkit is essential for any homeowner. It allows you to tackle minor repairs and conduct routine maintenance with confidence. Imagine the ...

48 Hours in Hobart: The Ultimate Weekend Itinerary

Nestled between the towering Mount Wellington and the sparkling waters of the Derwent River, Hobart is a charming city that offers an intriguing blend of natural beauty, rich histo...

Lunchtime Facelifts: Quick & Effective Procedures for Busy Professionals

Busy professionals often find themselves juggling demanding careers, family obligations, and social commitments. With such a tight schedule, it can be difficult to make time for ...

Visual Guide to Distinguishing Ants from Termites

Distinguishing ants from termites is crucial for homeowners who wish to protect their properties from structural damage. These tiny creatures, though seemingly unthreatening, can...

Times Magazine

First Nations Writers Festival

The First Nations Writers Festival (FNWF) is back for its highly anticipated 2025 edition, continuing its mission to celebrate the voices, cultures and traditions of First Nations communities through literature, art and storytelling. Set to take ...

Improving Website Performance with a Cloud VPS

Websites represent the new mantra of success. One slow website may make escape for visitors along with income too. Therefore it's an extra offer to businesses seeking better performance with more scalability and, thus represents an added attracti...

Why You Should Choose Digital Printing for Your Next Project

In the rapidly evolving world of print media, digital printing has emerged as a cornerstone technology that revolutionises how businesses and creative professionals produce printed materials. Offering unparalleled flexibility, speed, and quality, d...

What to Look for When Booking an Event Space in Melbourne

Define your event needs early to streamline venue selection and ensure a good fit. Choose a well-located, accessible venue with good transport links and parking. Check for key amenities such as catering, AV equipment, and flexible seating. Pla...

How BIM Software is Transforming Architecture and Engineering

Building Information Modeling (BIM) software has become a cornerstone of modern architecture and engineering practices, revolutionizing how professionals design, collaborate, and execute projects. By enabling more efficient workflows and fostering ...

How 32-Inch Computer Monitors Can Increase Your Workflow

With the near-constant usage of technology around the world today, ergonomics have become crucial in business. Moving to 32 inch computer monitors is perhaps one of the best and most valuable improvements you can possibly implement. This-sized moni...

LayBy Shopping