The Times Australia
Small Business News

.
The Times Real Estate

.

Workplace transmissions: a predictable result of the class divide in worker rights

  • Written by Kantha Dayaram, John Burgess and Scott Fitzgerald


How to stop sick people going to work?

That’s a question the Victorian government has been grappling with since it became clear about 80% of new COVID-19 infections in the state’s second-wave outbreak were from workplace transmissions.


Read more: 'Far too many' Victorians are going to work while sick. Far too many have no choice


After official visits to 3,000 people meant to be self-isolating found more than 800 not at home, the government instituted the largest on-the-spot fine in the state’s history – A$4,957 for defying a stay-at-home order (and up to $20,000 for going to work knowing you have COVID-19).

Join 130,000 people who subscribe to free evidence-based news.

Along with the big sticks, there have been carrots. The Victorian government, the Fair Work Commission and the federal government have all weighed in to provide financial support to workers who lack paid sick leave.

But these measures have been a belated band aid to a problem that should have been entirely predictable. It’s the consequence of a deepening class divide in work in which hundreds of thousands of essential workers in high-risk industries are poorly paid and lack job security, guaranteed hours or sick-leave entitlements.

Aged care workers

Aged-care homes (linked to more than 2,000) cases and meat-processing facilities (linked to about 870 cases) show the predicament of “flexible employment” for workers.

In the aged care sector, about 90% of carers are female, 32% born overseas, 78% permanent part-time and 10% casual or contract, according to the 2016 National Aged Care Workforce Census and Survey. Seven in ten are employed as personal care attendants. Of those, almost 60% work 16–34 hours a week, with a median wage of A$689. About 30% want to work more hours, and 9% work more than one job.

An underemployed workforce is advantageous to employers. As the Bankwest Curtin Economics Centre’s 2018 report on developing sustainable careers for aged care workers noted:

Underemployment offers organisations a buffer of additional hours that can be accessed when there are staff shortages. The regularity and predictability of hours is a challenge for workers, though, in terms of their lack of employment and income stability.

It might now be noted it also makes it problematic for them to turn down shifts, to stay home if they feel unwell, or to seek out a coronavirus test lest a positive result forces them to self-quarantine.

Australian Defence Force personnel arrive at Epping Gardens Aged Care Facility in Melbourne's north
Australian Defence Force personnel at Epping Gardens Aged Care Facility in Melbourne’s north. More than 200 COVID-19 cases have been linked to the home. Daniel Pockett/AAP

Meat processing workers

In red-meat-processing facilities, about 20% of the processing workforce is casual, according to a 2015 report by the Australian Meat Processor Corporation. These workers “can be terminated on any given day part-way through a shift”.

The rest of the workforce is barely more secure, with 80% employed as “daily hires”. This means their jobs technically terminate at the end of a shift. They can be sacked with just one day’s notice.

Media reports have highlighted the predicament for workers without paid sick leave. At the Golden Farms Turosi poultry processing site in Geelong, for example, media reported that workers told to self-isolate after a COVID-19 outbreak in July were then directed to return to work early to clean the premises.

The United Workers Union said the company expected its workers “to dip into their own entitlements or, for casuals, be left with nothing at all” during the stand-down. Glenn Myhre, a Golden Farms worker for 34 years, put it like this:

This is leaving a lot of people very insecure. Casuals and people with no entitlements are going to be left in a really tight spot.

Poultry processing facility
More than 900 Victorian coronavirus cases have been linked to meat processing facilities. Francois Lenoir/Reuters

Read more: When it comes to sick leave, we're not much better prepared for coronavirus than the US


Fair Work Commission decisions

It should not be surprising that those with insecure incomes and jobs would risk going to work when they do feel unwell.

Yet official appreciation of this has been slow.

In April the Fair Work Commission, Australia’s industrial relations arbiter, approved changes to more than 100 awards to provide two weeks’ pandemic leave for all employees, including casual workers. But the leave was unpaid.

On July 8 it deferred a union application for paid pandemic leave to health workers (to be paid by employers).

The commission accepted expert evidence that “at a high level of generality, workers in the health and social care sectors are at a higher risk of infection by COVID-19 (and other infectious diseases)”.

It also acknowledged the “very real risk” that employees with no paid leave entitlements “may not report any COVID-19-like symptoms or contact with someone suspected of having COVID-19 out of concern that they will suffer significant financial detriment”.

However, the commission ruled, “the elevated potential risk to health and care workers of actual or suspected exposure to infection has not manifested itself in actuality”.

Three weeks later, on July 27, as the disaster in Victoria’s aged care facilities unfolded, the commission granted paid pandemic leave to casual aged care workers.

Covering all workers

Ensuring paid pandemic leave for all workers has taken longer.

In June the Victorian government introduced a one-off A$1,500 “hardship payment” for workers left with no income if ordered to self-quarantine. It did not, however, cover lost income from self-isolating while awaiting the result of a COVID-19 test.

On August 3, the day after Victorian Premier Daniel Andrews declared a state of disaster and a stage 4 lockdown for Melbourne, the federal government announced a $1,500 “disaster payment” for all Victorians without paid leave entitlements who are ordered to self-isolate.

Then, after a joint call from the Australian Council of Trade Unions and the Business Council of Australia for a national paid pandemic leave, the federal government agreed to extend the disaster payment to all states and territories.

A festering class divide

The failure to anticipate this problem is one of the greatest flaws in Australia’s response to the pandemic.

The belated payments are a tacit acknowledgement of a systemic problem. It is one that needs more than a temporary band-aid.

For a society that prides itself on egalitarianism, the mounting evidence that vulnerable workers have borne the brunt of health and financial impacts calls for broad reform of an industrial relations system that has allowed a class divide in working conditions to fester.


Read more: What defines casual work? Federal Court ruling highlights a fundamental flaw in Australian labour law


To paraphrase the sociologist C. Wright Mills, the pandemic should motivate us to finally acknowledge as a public issue what has perhaps been too easily dismissed as the private troubles of individual workers.



This article first appeared in The Conversation. It is republished with permission.

SME Business News

2024 Retail Insights: What Consumer Trends and Sales Data Forecast for 2025

Holiday Consumer Spending Habits: Key Takeaways for Retail Strategy The period from November through January has consistently been pivotal for retailers, and 2024 has been no exception. This...

The Importance of SEO for Security Service Companies

In today's digital age, businesses must adapt to a constantly evolving online landscape, and SEO for Security Companies are no exception. Whether you offer private security, cybersecurity, or cor...

Maximising Business Efficiency with the Versatile Applications of Pallet Wrap

A pallet wrap may not look like much, but it is an important part of industrial packing, logistics, and managing the supply chain. The main reason it's used is to move goods quickly and safely...

Foxtel Group and World Surf League extend partnership into 2025

Foxtel Group has announced the renewal of its broadcast rights deal with the World Surf League (WSL), extending the long-standing, 17-year partnership through 2025. The renewal ensures Austra...

Property Times

Property Hotspots for Australia in 2025

Introduction As we move into a new era of property investment, understanding the concept of property hotspots becomes essential for investors looking to maximize their returns. A property hotspot is typically defined as a location where property p...

Building Inspections on the Gold Coast: Protecting Your Investment

The Gold Coast is a beautiful place to own property, but its unique environment demands extra care and attention.  On the surface, a Gold Coast property might appear pristine. The paint looks fresh, the structure seems solid and everything feels p...

From Classroom to Property Mogul: Lloyd Edge Shares His Journey and His Blueprint for Property Success

Lloyd Edge’s career trajectory is far from conventional. A former high school teacher, he’s now one of Australia’s leading property experts. But the transition from educator to property mogul didn’t happen overnight. It was a result of hard work...

Positive signs in new home construction but still a long way to go

In the first three months of the National Housing Accord, Australia commenced construction on 43,247 new homes according to the Australian Bureau of Statistics. This is 4.6 per cent higher than the June 2024 quarter and 13.9 per cent higher than t...

Food & Dining

Fresh Ideas for Celebrating the Year of the Snake

The Lunar New Year is here, and with it comes the Year of the Snake—a time for fresh beginnings, family connections, and, of course, delicious food. As celebrations kick off, Australian families are turning to summer’s bounty of fresh produce to ...

Drop of Sunshine | The perfect gift for that special someone this Valentine’s day

Drop of Sunshine: A Toast to Women, Our Connections & The Stories That Bring Us Together Treasury Wine Estates (TWE), one of the world’s leading wine companies, has launched a new line of premium wines,  Drop of Sunshine, in partnership wit...

Delicious and Healthy Vitamix Recipes for Optimal Nutrition

🍏🥦 Enjoy tasty Vitamix recipes packed with nutrients for optimum health. Healthy eating 🥕🍓 made fun & delicious! 💪🍹 #Nutrition #VitamixRecipes Healthy Eating and Optimal NutritionRenowned for its versatility and unparalleled blending capabilitie...

Lauren’s Journey to a Healthier Life: How Being a Busy Mum and Supportive Wife Helped Her To Lose 51kg with The Lady Shake

For Lauren, the road to better health began with a small and simple but significant decision. As a busy wife and mother, she noticed her husband skipping breakfast and decided to purchase The Man Shake to ensure he was starting his day right. W...

The Times Features

Here's How to Pick the Best Hair Loss Treatment for Your Needs

Hair loss can be frustrating, probably an emotional experience, and only with appropriate types of treatments is one able to restore one's confidence level, showing results that ...

Property Hotspots for Australia in 2025

Introduction As we move into a new era of property investment, understanding the concept of property hotspots becomes essential for investors looking to maximize their returns. ...

INTRO Travel Predicts 2025’s Top Travel Hotspots

They’re Giving Away a Free Trip! As young travellers look ahead to 2025, certain destinations are already emerging as must-visit hotspots. According to INTRO Travel—an Austral...

Vitamin B6 is essential – but too much can be toxic. Here’s what to know to stay safe

In recent weeks, reports have been circulating[1] about severe reactions in people who’ve taken over-the-counter vitamin B6 supplements. Vitamin B6 poisoning can injure nerv...

The Benefits of Solar-Powered Heating and Cooling

As the climate becomes more unpredictable and temperatures continue to rise, staying cool during the hotter months is more important than ever. Traditional air conditioners, wh...

Cool T-Shirts for Men: Trends, Styles, and Must-Haves

People are fond of cool t-shirts for men. These allow the boys to show their personality. Yes, it works like a canvas that men use to do self-expression. Trendy men’s t-shirts ma...

Business Times

2024 Retail Insights: What Consumer Trends and Sales Data Forecas…

Holiday Consumer Spending Habits: Key Takeaways for Retail Strategy The period from November through January has consist...

The Importance of SEO for Security Service Companies

In today's digital age, businesses must adapt to a constantly evolving online landscape, and SEO for Security Companies are n...

Maximising Business Efficiency with the Versatile Applications of…

A pallet wrap may not look like much, but it is an important part of industrial packing, logistics, and managing the supply...

LayBy Shopping