The Times Australia
The Times News

.
Beatbot

.

New Zealand's legal aid crisis is eroding the right to justice – that's unacceptable in a fair society

  • Written by Kris Gledhill, Professor of Law, Auckland University of Technology
New Zealand's legal aid crisis is eroding the right to justice – that's unacceptable in a fair society

Most lawyers are happy to accept we’ll never be as popular as doctors. We are probably on a level with dentists: nobody really wants to see them – until they have a toothache.

Same with lawyers. Having to sort out a legal dispute without a lawyer can often be as problematic as doing dentistry on yourself.

Disputes about all sorts of things – bullying bosses, violent spouses, governmental overreach, custody of children, what happens to people with dementia – can end up in court. Judges are given significant powers over us. They can take away liberty, property and children; they can order psychiatric treatment.

That is why the right to a fair trial is such a fundamental one – and why the legal aid system is integral to that fairness. So, the recent Law Society survey of lawyers[1] that found the legal aid system is “on life support” is cause for deep concern.

Balancing the odds

Our court system is largely based on the adversarial model, whereby arguments are made from those involved and the neutral judge (or judge and jury) makes a decision. This requires what is termed “equality of arms” – essentially, equal access to lawyers.

Otherwise, there is an imbalance, which might lead to an unfair result with significant adverse consequences. This is also why legal aid is of fundamental importance to a society that values equity.

Governments, corporations and well-resourced organisations will invariably have lawyers. Society pays for these in full if they are working for public bodies. Society also pays in part for lawyers who represent commercial bodies, since their fees will be allowable against income and so, will reduce taxes paid.

Read more: Protesting during a pandemic: New Zealand's balancing act between a long tradition of protests and COVID rules[2]

It has long been accepted that society has to provide lawyers for those who face the power of the state in criminal proceedings. In 1912, the New Zealand Parliament enacted a legal aid system[3] for criminal defendants who did not have sufficient means. The starting point was to pay those lawyers at the same rate as prosecuting lawyers.

But many important decisions are also made in the civil courts. A legal aid scheme for civil proceedings[4] was introduced in 1939, aimed at “poor people”.

When the system was revised and extended in 1969[5], the aim was to make better provision for those of “small or moderate means”. This also proposed that legal aid lawyers should be paid 85% of the rate they would otherwise have charged.

Lawyers abandoning legal aid

Much has changed since. If you get legal aid now, it is in the form of a loan – rarely written off – bearing interest[6] and leading to caveats on any assets.

But it is more likely you won’t be granted legal aid at all, because only those with severely constrained resources[7] qualify.

Read more: NZ's hate speech proposals need more detail and wider debate before they become law[8]

And, as the Law Society survey shows, even if you do qualify there is a good chance you won’t be able to find a lawyer. The survey found over 60% of lawyers have no interest in doing legal aid work. Of those who are willing, many have to limit the numbers of cases they can take on.

This means legally aided clients are more likely to be turned away. The situation will probably worsen, too, because a quarter of those willing to do legal aid are planning to do less in the future.

Red tape and low pay

Among the other problems identified by the surveyed lawyers is the level of bureaucracy they face. This can be traced back to a review of legal aid[9] in 2009, which led to the current legislative framework under the Legal Services Act 2011.

The review placed a heavy reliance on anecdotal evidence of misbehaviour by some lawyers. It has always been true that legally aided spending has to be justified, but the current regime seems to be micro-managed.

The other significant problem is that legal aid pay rates are low[10] and haven’t changed for many years. It’s not just that lawyers can earn more – a lot more – if they avoid legal aid. It’s that legal aid rates sometimes barely cover their costs.

When legal academics ask law students why they want to be lawyers, the desire to help people in difficult situations is a common answer. This can be especially true for students from groups who face more disadvantage, including Māori, Pacific Island and refugee communities.

But those desires can only go so far if the work does not provide a living.

Read more: Criminal lawyers are regularly exposed to trauma — how can NZ's justice system look after them better?[11]

Eroding the right to justice

Of course, it is easy to be cynical about lawyers asking for funding for lawyers. This comes back to the image problem. Contrast it with medical professionals calling for a better-funded health service, including better pay for doctors and nurses. The public is generally sympathetic.

But just as access to health is a good thing, so is access to justice. They are both prerequisites for a decent society.

If we go back to the origins of legal aid, it involved a recognition that relying on charity was not an appropriate response when the stakes are high. There was an acceptance fair trials are a keystone of the justice system, and legal aid can contribute to equal access to justice for all.

This right to justice is recognised in the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990[12]. But it is being hollowed out as time goes by, as fewer people can obtain legal aid and fewer lawyers are willing to do such work.

The Law Society survey suggests urgent action is required to avoid a justice gap that should be unacceptable in modern New Zealand.

References

  1. ^ Law Society survey of lawyers (www.lawsociety.org.nz)
  2. ^ Protesting during a pandemic: New Zealand's balancing act between a long tradition of protests and COVID rules (theconversation.com)
  3. ^ enacted a legal aid system (www.nzlii.org)
  4. ^ legal aid scheme for civil proceedings (www.nzlii.org)
  5. ^ revised and extended in 1969 (www.nzlii.org)
  6. ^ bearing interest (www.rnz.co.nz)
  7. ^ severely constrained resources (www.legislation.govt.nz)
  8. ^ NZ's hate speech proposals need more detail and wider debate before they become law (theconversation.com)
  9. ^ review of legal aid (www.beehive.govt.nz)
  10. ^ pay rates are low (www.rnz.co.nz)
  11. ^ Criminal lawyers are regularly exposed to trauma — how can NZ's justice system look after them better? (theconversation.com)
  12. ^ New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 (www.legislation.govt.nz)

Read more https://theconversation.com/new-zealands-legal-aid-crisis-is-eroding-the-right-to-justice-thats-unacceptable-in-a-fair-society-171663

The Times Features

Discover Heartwarming WWF Gifts for Every Animal Lover

With holiday season upon us, what better way to spread festive joy than with gifts that make a real difference. The WWF, a renowned wildlife and nature charity offers a range...

The Foods You Should Avoid When Drinking Rose Wine

Rose wine has been synonymous with romance, and it’s easy to know why. This light and fruity drink invites you to relax, let loose, and just enjoy life’s simple pleasures.  But ...

How digital loyalty programs drive engagement in a value-conscious economy

Ongoing economic pressures are driving Australian retail businesses to rethink how they engage with increasingly value-conscious consumers. Rising living costs have shifted spe...

Does menopause hormone therapy increase or decrease your risk of dementia? Here’s the science

By 2050, around 135 million people[1] worldwide will be living with dementia. The most common cause of dementia is Alzheimer’s disease. Women are more likely than men to develo...

Amy Gerard's Top Tips to Decorating Your Tree this Christmas

Tip 1: Start with the Perfect Tree Skip the frustration of tangled lights by investing in a Balsam Hill Christmas tree with built in lights. With this, you never have to wre...

SPICE AND BLACK VANILLA EAU DE TOILETTE FROM CREMO LAUNCHES IN AUSTRALIA

Sitting as the U. S best-seller in Men’s Cologne on Amazon, the fragrance is now available to purchase in Australia Having amassed a dedicated cult following on TikTok and cap...

Times Magazine

Full capacity: 5 steps to avoid forklift damage

There is a very good reason why Australia maintains rigorous forklift safety standards. The truth is, not everyone can be trusted on this dangerous machinery, and the uninitiated are simply a risk to themselves, their colleagues and the machine. ...

Secure Your Precious Cargo With Car Seat Installation

The experience of traveling with kids is unique, but it can also be anxiety-inducing. It's crucial to ensure that your children's car seats are installed properly if you want to guarantee their security and safety while you're driving. You may fe...

Make Mom Smile on Her Special Day by Showing Your Love with Mother's Day Flowers

Mother's Day is the perfect time to show your mum just how much she means to you, and what better way to do that than with a beautiful bouquet! Whether you choose a stunning arrangement of roses, lilies, and sunflowers, or a cheerful mix of daisies...

Upgrade Your Gaming Setup this Black Friday from TEMU

This year, Black Friday is set to be a record-breaker in Australia, with a staggering $6.7 billion expected to be spent over the four-day shopping period. As Aussies get ready to snap up deals, 1 in 10 are looking to TEMU, the online marketplace ...

The Reasons Why You Should Never Leave Your Car At An Outdoor Car Park

Surveys show that Australia is the most expensive country in the world to park in! The average daily parking charges were in the region of AUD 35 in 2022, and they showed no signs of coming down. Parking in the CBDs (central business districts) c...

Managing Your Online Reputation: Strategies for Removing Negative Content

Maintaining a positive online reputation is crucial for individuals and businesses in today's digital age. However, negative content such as negative reviews, defamatory posts, or outdated information can tarnish your reputation and harm your credi...

LayBy Shopping