The Times Australia
Business and Money
The Times Real Estate

.

despite the tough talk, the closure of Tiwai Point is far from a done deal

  • Written by Geoff Bertram, Senior Associate, Institute for Governance and Policy Studies, Te Herenga Waka — Victoria University of Wellington

Another year, another round of hostage-taking by the owners of the Tiwai Point aluminium smelter.

As always, Rio Tinto has made the first move, threatening to close[1] New Zealand Aluminium Smelters (NZAS) in Southland unless some ransom is paid. A thousand jobs would be lost, with a further 1,600 indirectly affected.

In the usual script the New Zealand government caves in and smelting rolls on while Rio Tinto and its local allies pocket their gains.

Will this time be different? As with any ransom demand, the questions are whether the threat is credible and how bad the consequences of refusing would be.

Will the smelter really close?

Cutting the smelter’s power price by a third is apparently the demand[2] this time. Given the history (and the National Party’s unclear position) there is a real possibility the eventual outcome (after the election) could be another ransom payment and another few years of aluminium production.

A win for Rio Tinto could take several forms. The government could pay a cash ransom (as in 2013[3]). Or Meridian Energy (supplier to Tiwai Point) could give up a chunk of its revenue. Or the big five electricity generators could share the ransom among themselves as a means of staving off a fall in residential power prices.

Read more: The market is not our master — only state-led business cooperation will drive real economic recovery[4]

Alternatively, the Electricity Authority, always a compliant lapdog of the “gentailer” (generator-retailer) cartel, could provide the industry with cover by mandating price discounts[5] for other power companies too.

If nobody blinks, we will find out whether the closure threat was really credible.

We can immediately set aside the smelter’s “NZ$46 million loss[6]” declared for the past year. The accounts of both NZAS[7] (the smelter operator) and Pacific Aluminium NZ Ltd[8] are (quite legally) arranged to produce whatever profit/loss (and associated tax liability[9]) the overseas owners want.

The final decision would be a strategic one for Rio Tinto: reputational benefits of being seen to punish a recalcitrant host economy, versus the loss of a renewables-powered smelter in an increasingly carbon-conscious world.

It really could go either way and I’m laying no bets.

despite the tough talk, the closure of Tiwai Point is far from a done deal Renewable-energy-powered aluminium: could a carbon-conscious world influence Rio Tinto’s calculations? Marc Daalder

How could we use the extra electricity?

We can, however, get a handle on possible policy responses to actual closure. The biggest impact, from which potentially big gains could come, is the freed-up electricity from the Manapouri power station.

Getting that amount of electricity (13% of the country’s entire consumption[10]) to anywhere other than Bluff is not a simple matter, because it will need a new transmission line from Manapouri to Benmore or Christchurch. That line has never been built, and to build it now will take time and money.

Transpower is reported[11] to be finally getting to work, but don’t expect an immediate result.

Read more: Unless we improve the law, history shows rushing shovel-ready projects comes with real risk[12]

You might well think that building that line decades ago would have provided the New Zealand government with an essential bargaining chip (the “outside option” of reallocating the electricity if the smelter closed).

Certainly by failing to take that step, the state has declared a lack of will to resist ransom demands, which probably gave the smelter owners confidence in repeating those demands.

Suppose the line is built, what gain could residential consumers see? Well, it depends.

If the smelter’s contract is simply ended and Meridian is left looking for a new buyer, this might break the big-generator cartel and bring prices down. Or it might just lead to collective market manipulation to protect their share prices. (Contact is already talking[13] of pausing a new geothermal project.)

despite the tough talk, the closure of Tiwai Point is far from a done deal The Tiwai Point control room: 13% of New Zealand’s electricity flows through the smelter. Marc Daalder

What if the government became a player?

Alternatively, suppose the government summons up the courage to compulsorily acquire Rio Tinto’s contract rights (which run to 2030) and thus becomes the “single buyer” of 5,000 gigawatt hours (GWh) of electricity a year.

The government would then be able to dispose of this electricity as it sees fit. If it were to put the material well-being of households (in particular the poor ones) at the top of its priorities, it could supply those consumers with a fair chunk of their annual electricity consumption at a price far below the regular market wholesale price.

Read more: Owners of electric vehicles to be paid to plug into the grid to help avoid blackouts[14]

It could do this even within the current (deeply flawed) electricity market structure, leaving supply and demand to play out for the rest of the 40,000 GWh of annual generation.

Readers with long memories may recall the 1992 Hydro New Zealand proposal, which sought to protect vulnerable consumers from rising prices under corporatisation and privatisation by locking in just such a long-term, low-price “vesting contract”.

There is, however, a softer option open to the government, which would mollify Southland while leaving the crucial transmission line unbuilt.

That is the time-honoured Think Big tradition of installing some new, heavily subsidised giant electricity-using industry at Bluff – perhaps a “green hydrogen” plant, perhaps a data centre or even a Tesla “gigafactory[15]”.

Remember, the government has a big stake in the profitability of three of the big generators. Watch this space – and don’t expect your power bills to come down any time soon.

References

  1. ^ threatening to close (www.stuff.co.nz)
  2. ^ apparently the demand (www.pressreader.com)
  3. ^ as in 2013 (www.stuff.co.nz)
  4. ^ The market is not our master — only state-led business cooperation will drive real economic recovery (theconversation.com)
  5. ^ price discounts (www.stuff.co.nz)
  6. ^ NZ$46 million loss (www.odt.co.nz)
  7. ^ NZAS (app.companiesoffice.govt.nz)
  8. ^ Pacific Aluminium NZ Ltd (app.companiesoffice.govt.nz)
  9. ^ tax liability (www.riotinto.com)
  10. ^ 13% of the country’s entire consumption (www.rnz.co.nz)
  11. ^ reported (www.stuff.co.nz)
  12. ^ Unless we improve the law, history shows rushing shovel-ready projects comes with real risk (theconversation.com)
  13. ^ already talking (www.scoop.co.nz)
  14. ^ Owners of electric vehicles to be paid to plug into the grid to help avoid blackouts (theconversation.com)
  15. ^ gigafactory (www.stuff.co.nz)

Authors: Geoff Bertram, Senior Associate, Institute for Governance and Policy Studies, Te Herenga Waka — Victoria University of Wellington

Read more https://theconversation.com/power-play-despite-the-tough-talk-the-closure-of-tiwai-point-is-far-from-a-done-deal-142372

SME Business News

Why Your Dental Business Needs Professional Digital Marketing Services

Running a successful dental practice today requires more than just great patient care. In a digital-first world, your online presence plays a huge role in how potential patients discover, choos...

Brand Storytelling: How Video Marketing Can Enhance Your Brand Identity

In the competitive landscape of 2025, building a strong and recognisable brand identity is crucial for standing out in the marketplace. One of the most effective ways to shape and communicate y...

Future-Proofing Your Business with Strategic Defence Insight

In an era marked by rapid technological change, global uncertainty, and evolving security risks, the need for long-term resilience in business has never been greater. Organisations across indu...

Maximise Your Amazon Profits with These 5 Simple Seller Strategies

Selling on Amazon offers countless opportunities for individuals and businesses to grow their income. But with so many sellers joining the platform every day, it’s not enough to just list your ...

The Times Features

The Best Adjustable Bed and Mattress Packages for Comfort

The appropriate bed and mattress are essential for establishing the perfect sleep environment. If you seek a way to upgrade your sleep experience, adjustable bed and mattress pac...

Designing a Modern Home: Features That Will Make Your Dream House Stand Out

Designing your dream home is an exciting journey, and for many, it’s an opportunity to create a space that reflects their personal style, functionality needs, and modern trends. ...

Client Dinners Done Right: Tips for Meaningful Engagement

Client dinners offer more than just a meal—they’re an opportunity to build lasting business relationships in a more personal and relaxed setting. Done well, these dinners can str...

From Classic to Contemporary: 5 Timeless Costumes for Any Party

When it comes to dressing up for a costume party, you want to choose something that is not only fun but also memorable. Whether you're attending a Halloween event, a themed gathe...

Action Figures as Art: The Growing Trend of Custom Figures and Modding

Action figures have long been regarded as collectible items, valued by enthusiasts and fans for their connection to popular culture. However, in recent years, a growing trend has...

The Ultimate Guide to Securing Grants for Your Small Business in Australia

Running a small business in Australia comes with both opportunities and challenges. While it can be rewarding, funding your business through the early stages or periods of growth...

Business Times

Why Your Dental Business Needs Professional Digital Marketing Ser…

Running a successful dental practice today requires more than just great patient care. In a digital-first world, your onlin...

Brand Storytelling: How Video Marketing Can Enhance Your Brand Id…

In the competitive landscape of 2025, building a strong and recognisable brand identity is crucial for standing out in the ...

Future-Proofing Your Business with Strategic Defence Insight

In an era marked by rapid technological change, global uncertainty, and evolving security risks, the need for long-term res...

LayBy Shopping