The Times Australia
Business and Money
The Times Real Estate

.

why is Australia such a tough market for the cruise ship industry?

  • Written by Freya Higgins-Desbiolles, Adjunct Senior Lecturer in Tourism Management/ Adjunct Associate Professor, University of South Australia
why is Australia such a tough market for the cruise ship industry?

Miami-based cruise operator Carnival Corporation has announced[1] it will retire its P&O Cruises Australia brand in March 2025.

The decision marks the end of the line for an iconic cruise brand in Australia and the Pacific, after nearly a century[2] of operations.

Parent company Carnival has been on a campaign of international growth through acquisitions and mergers since at least 1989. P&O Cruises Australia was bought by the company in 2003.

Many Australians might remember the brand’s iconic television advertisements from the 1980s and ‘90s that encouraged them to escape the rat race.

P&O’s memorable advertisements from the 1980s and 1990s encouraged Australians to escape the rat race.

But the reality of cruising’s international consolidation leaves little room for such nostalgia and national brand attachment.

Still, cruising is a big part of Australia’s tourism sector, and cruises are a large source of inbound visitors. The Australian Cruise Association estimates the industry’s total economic contribution[3] is as high as A$5.63 billion.

Australians are hungry for cruise ship experiences. They make up the fourth largest[4] source market for passengers, at 1.25 million last year.

Australia is a tough place to make a profit

A recent report[5] by Cruise Lines International Association painted a picture of a thriving industry. New, bigger ships are being rolled out to meet a growing market of both new and loyal cruise enthusiasts.

So why are operators struggling here? P&O hasn’t been the only brand facing difficulties down under.

P&O cruise ship docked in Melbourne Australia
Carnival will retire its iconic P&O Australia brand in early 2025. Sunflowerey/Shutterstock[6]

P&O’s sister line Cunard recently announced it will stop basing itself[7] in Australia from 2026, and Virgin Voyages’ Resilient Lady has cancelled plans[8] for a second sailing season here next summer.

Carnival said[9] its decision on P&O Australia came down to the region’s “significantly higher operating and regulatory costs” and small population. The company said it had been forced to change its operating approach to achieve “efficiencies”.

The cruise sector was hit hard by the pandemic. In early 2020, Carnival reported a staggering single quarter net loss of US$4.4 billion[10]. The company also suffered reputational damage following a high-profile COVID outbreak[11] on its Ruby Princess cruise ship.

The international cruise market is heavily concentrated. Almost 80%[12] of the passenger market is shared by three big companies: Carnival, Royal Caribbean International and Norwegian cruise lines.

Australia’s high operating costs and relatively small market make it tough for big cruise companies to achieve the profitability they expect. Carnival’s Cunard Line attributed its decision to move out[13] of Melbourne to a 15% hike in port fees.

Three different cruise ships docked near a beach in Nassau in the Bahamas
Most of the international cruise market is concentrated within the ‘big three’ operators – Carnival, Royal Caribbean International and Norwegian. Paulharding00/Shutterstock[14]

As these companies have sought to strengthen their competitive advantage, acquiring smaller players has been a popular strategy.

This mass tourism model can deliver relatively cheap holidays for passengers. But it often also sacrifices well-loved smaller cruise operations that are more connected to local histories and cultures.

There is also the tyranny of distance for Australia, and increasing geopolitical risks affecting cruising.

The Australasian region faces stiff competition as a cruise destination from alternatives such as the Caribbean and the Mediterranean, which are close to large markets. Virgin Voyages said its cancellation of the 2024–25 sailing schedule was due to major safety concerns in the Red Sea.

What does its future hold?

Reassuringly, customers with P&O bookings for the remainder of 2024 will not be affected. Next year, the brand’s Pacific Encounter and Pacific Adventure ships will continue to sail, but under new branding for Carnival Cruise Line. Pacific Explorer will be retired from service.

In Australia, the mass tourism model of the big cruise operators is no doubt here to stay. But there could be further cuts to the range of destination ports offered as the industry prioritises profits.

In the longer term, however, a crucial question concerns the future of ports around Australia that have been enticed into engaging with the cruise industry. Many government tourism authorities have been keen to expand the sector.

As a result, access to some smaller ports has been negotiated and there has been a push to build new facilities in New South Wales, the biggest market.

Tourists walk along a track toward the Bungle Bungles in the Kimberley
Small ship cruise operators offer expeditions to regions such as the Kimberley in WA. Rachel Claire/Pexels[15]

This has received pushback[16] from some parts of the community who argue the economic benefits don’t outweigh the cultural and ecological cost.

In the future, there could be a more sustainable solution for Australian cruising in smaller expedition-like formats. These have been particularly successful in locations such as the Kimberley in Western Australia.

Local communities at small-ship destinations may find this model of cruising more acceptable, given its lower passenger numbers and smaller environmental impact.

References

  1. ^ announced (www.carnivalaustralia.com)
  2. ^ nearly a century (www.pocruises.com.au)
  3. ^ total economic contribution (www.australiancruiseassociation.com)
  4. ^ fourth largest (www.cruising.org.au)
  5. ^ recent report (cruising.org)
  6. ^ Sunflowerey/Shutterstock (shutterstock.com)
  7. ^ stop basing itself (www.cruisehive.com)
  8. ^ cancelled plans (www.smh.com.au)
  9. ^ said (www.carnivalaustralia.com)
  10. ^ US$4.4 billion (www.reuters.com)
  11. ^ high-profile COVID outbreak (www.bbc.com)
  12. ^ 80% (cruisemarketwatch.com)
  13. ^ move out (www.canberratimes.com.au)
  14. ^ Paulharding00/Shutterstock (www.shutterstock.com)
  15. ^ Rachel Claire/Pexels (www.pexels.com)
  16. ^ pushback (www.nsw.gov.au)

Authors: Freya Higgins-Desbiolles, Adjunct Senior Lecturer in Tourism Management/ Adjunct Associate Professor, University of South Australia

Read more https://theconversation.com/end-of-the-line-for-pando-why-is-australia-such-a-tough-market-for-the-cruise-ship-industry-231607

SME Business News

2024 Retail Insights: What Consumer Trends and Sales Data Forecast for 2025

Holiday Consumer Spending Habits: Key Takeaways for Retail Strategy The period from November through January has consistently been pivotal for retailers, and 2024 has been no exception. This...

The Importance of SEO for Security Service Companies

In today's digital age, businesses must adapt to a constantly evolving online landscape, and SEO for Security Companies are no exception. Whether you offer private security, cybersecurity, or cor...

Maximising Business Efficiency with the Versatile Applications of Pallet Wrap

A pallet wrap may not look like much, but it is an important part of industrial packing, logistics, and managing the supply chain. The main reason it's used is to move goods quickly and safely...

Foxtel Group and World Surf League extend partnership into 2025

Foxtel Group has announced the renewal of its broadcast rights deal with the World Surf League (WSL), extending the long-standing, 17-year partnership through 2025. The renewal ensures Austra...

The Times Features

Here's How to Pick the Best Hair Loss Treatment for Your Needs

Hair loss can be frustrating, probably an emotional experience, and only with appropriate types of treatments is one able to restore one's confidence level, showing results that ...

Property Hotspots for Australia in 2025

Introduction As we move into a new era of property investment, understanding the concept of property hotspots becomes essential for investors looking to maximize their returns. ...

INTRO Travel Predicts 2025’s Top Travel Hotspots

They’re Giving Away a Free Trip! As young travellers look ahead to 2025, certain destinations are already emerging as must-visit hotspots. According to INTRO Travel—an Austral...

Vitamin B6 is essential – but too much can be toxic. Here’s what to know to stay safe

In recent weeks, reports have been circulating[1] about severe reactions in people who’ve taken over-the-counter vitamin B6 supplements. Vitamin B6 poisoning can injure nerv...

The Benefits of Solar-Powered Heating and Cooling

As the climate becomes more unpredictable and temperatures continue to rise, staying cool during the hotter months is more important than ever. Traditional air conditioners, wh...

Cool T-Shirts for Men: Trends, Styles, and Must-Haves

People are fond of cool t-shirts for men. These allow the boys to show their personality. Yes, it works like a canvas that men use to do self-expression. Trendy men’s t-shirts ma...

Business Times

2024 Retail Insights: What Consumer Trends and Sales Data Forecas…

Holiday Consumer Spending Habits: Key Takeaways for Retail Strategy The period from November through January has consist...

The Importance of SEO for Security Service Companies

In today's digital age, businesses must adapt to a constantly evolving online landscape, and SEO for Security Companies are n...

Maximising Business Efficiency with the Versatile Applications of…

A pallet wrap may not look like much, but it is an important part of industrial packing, logistics, and managing the supply...

LayBy Shopping