The Times Australia
Mirvac Harbourside
The Times World News

.

What today's GOP demonstrates about the dangers of partisan conformity

  • Written by Robert B. Talisse, W. Alton Jones Professor of Philosophy, Vanderbilt University

Directly following the 2020 election, Republicans seemed to be through with Donald Trump. Party leaders[1] stopped speaking to him and voters began abandoning the GOP[2], apparently in reaction to Trump’s role in the Jan. 6 Capitol riot.

Recently, things have changed. Republicans are once again aligning with Trump[3], even to the point of alienating GOP members[4] who criticize Trump for lying about the election[5].

The party’s reuniting with Trump may seem puzzling. A one-term and twice-impeached president with a consistently low approval rating[6] ordinarily would be a liability. Yet the GOP’s return to Trump is not really a surprise, because of the psychological forces known as belief polarization[7] and the black sheep effect[8].

Though these forces explain why the GOP is sticking with Trump, they also spell trouble.

To be politically successful, coalitions need to be unified. But unity can go only so far. As pressures to unify mount among group members, groups tend to factionalize, splinter and shrink.

And as a coalition shrinks, it becomes less effective in the political arena. This dynamic teaches an important lesson about democracy: To avoid splintering, partisans need to take steps to welcome dissent within their groups.

What today's GOP demonstrates about the dangers of partisan conformity Former U.S. President Donald Trump addresses the North Carolina GOP state convention on June 5, 2021, in Greenville, North Carolina. Melissa Sue Gerrits/Getty Images[9]

From unity to extremism

Belief polarization[10] is a strikingly common[11] phenomenon. When people interact only with like-minded others, they transform into more extreme versions of themselves: They come to adopt more radical versions of their beliefs and grow more confident of the truth of those beliefs.

In shifting toward more extreme beliefs, people also come to see those with whom they disagree as irrational, corrupt and depraved[12].

Yet, as I document in my forthcoming book, “Sustaining Democracy[13],” our more extreme selves are also more conformist[14]. Belief polarization leads group members to become both more extreme and more alike[15]. As members grow more uniform, they also become increasingly resolute in enforcing conformity. Thus, the group becomes less tolerant of dissension within its ranks and more prone to expel deviating members.

As pressure to conform intensifies, the group also comes to define itself more strictly in terms of its animosity toward other groups[16].

Eventually group membership[17] expands[18] into an entire lifestyle[19] set in opposition to rivals. Belief-polarized groups thus insulate themselves from contact with outsiders.

This goes a long way toward explaining the divide between “red” and “blue” states. Even within diverse American cities there tend to be distinct “liberal” and “conservative”[20] districts[21].

With this insularity comes increasing reliance on central leaders to establish the standards for authentic group membership. This makes the group internally hierarchical and increasingly fixated on consensus and purity. Belief-polarized groups are also highly susceptible to the black sheep effect[22], the tendency to dislike lapsed or deviant members of one’s own group more intensely than one dislikes members of rival groups.

Thus, as belief polarization takes effect, true believers seek to punish and purge anyone appearing to be halfhearted, inauthentic or disloyal. The result is that belief-polarized groups tend to splinter and expel members until only the most extreme and devoted remain.

GOP polarization

From my perspective as a political philosopher[23], I believe this is where the GOP finds itself.

Belief polarization has become well entrenched within the party after at least four years of defining itself as pro-Trump and in opposition to the Democratic Party[24], leaving it in need of central leadership that can corral the membership and set the agenda.

This partly explains why Rep. Liz Cheney was removed from her leadership position in the GOP despite her being more conservative[25] than the average Republican House member and having a record of reliably voting[26] for Trump’s legislative agenda.

To the GOP rank and file, Cheney’s relentless criticism of Trump shows a lack of fidelity to the Republican Party.

Belief polarization also makes sense of why Rep. Elise Stefanik was chosen as Cheney’s successor[27] in the House GOP leadership. Although Stefanik is less conservative[28] than Cheney, she is a Trump loyalist who, in accepting her new leadership role, pledged to forge “unity”[29] within the GOP.

As the context of her remarks made clear, by “unity” Stefanik meant uniformity in the party’s public stance. She was sure to indicate that the party would be “unified” in working with Trump, whom she thanked as a “crucial part of our Republican team.”

Belief polarization shows that there’s a price to pay for that kind of unity. Whatever short-term gains there may be in sticking together, eventually conformist groups fragment.

Former Vice President Mike Pence, heckled as a “traitor” at a recent conference for conservatives.

Be careful what you wish for

Consequently, further turmoil within the GOP should be expected. With escalating pressure to conform to Trump’s vision of the party, more members will likely be shunned and disciplined as “RINOs”[30] – “Republicans In Name Only” – or worse, including former Vice President Mike Pence[31].

The current state of the GOP offers a broad lesson for democratic politics. In a democracy, anyone who wants an effective political voice needs to join a choir of similar voices. Political coalitions are thus an indispensable feature of a democratic society.

However, such alliances expose people to forces that push them to more extreme beliefs and drive them to insist upon conformity among allies.

Both pressures are debilitating for political objectives. In a democracy, movements seek to expand coalitions and broaden alliances. Belief polarization presses in the opposite direction, leading toward greater intensity of conviction, but ultimately toward the dissolution of coalitions.

Americans hear a lot about the need for bipartisanship[32]. Surely “reaching across the aisle” is an important part of democracy.

But such efforts are futile unless partisans welcome rather than punish dissent within their ranks.

References

  1. ^ Party leaders (www.washingtonpost.com)
  2. ^ abandoning the GOP (www.usnews.com)
  3. ^ aligning with Trump (www.bloomberg.com)
  4. ^ alienating GOP members (www.nytimes.com)
  5. ^ lying about the election (www.huffpost.com)
  6. ^ low approval rating (fortune.com)
  7. ^ belief polarization (theconversation.com)
  8. ^ black sheep effect (dictionary.apa.org)
  9. ^ Melissa Sue Gerrits/Getty Images (www.gettyimages.com)
  10. ^ Belief polarization (blogs.cardiff.ac.uk)
  11. ^ strikingly common (doi.org)
  12. ^ irrational, corrupt and depraved (www.pewresearch.org)
  13. ^ Sustaining Democracy (global.oup.com)
  14. ^ extreme selves are also more conformist (quillette.com)
  15. ^ more extreme and more alike (oro.open.ac.uk)
  16. ^ animosity toward other groups (doi.org)
  17. ^ group membership (pcl.stanford.edu)
  18. ^ expands (onlinelibrary.wiley.com)
  19. ^ lifestyle (theconversation.com)
  20. ^ there tend to be distinct “liberal” and “conservative” (theconversation.com)
  21. ^ districts (projects.fivethirtyeight.com)
  22. ^ black sheep effect (doi.org)
  23. ^ my perspective as a political philosopher (scholar.google.com)
  24. ^ pro-Trump and in opposition to the Democratic Party (www.npr.org)
  25. ^ more conservative (heritageaction.com)
  26. ^ reliably voting (www.washingtonpost.com)
  27. ^ Rep. Elise Stefanik was chosen as Cheney’s successor (www.npr.org)
  28. ^ less conservative (www.businessinsider.com)
  29. ^ forge “unity” (www.cnn.com)
  30. ^ “RINOs” (www.newsweek.com)
  31. ^ Mike Pence (thehill.com)
  32. ^ need for bipartisanship (www.washingtonpost.com)

Read more https://theconversation.com/what-todays-gop-demonstrates-about-the-dangers-of-partisan-conformity-161401

Mirvac Harbourside

Times Magazine

YepAI Joins Victoria's AI Trade Mission to Singapore for Big Data & AI World Asia 2025

YepAI, a Melbourne-based leader in enterprise artificial intelligence solutions, announced today...

Building a Strong Online Presence with Katoomba Web Design

Katoomba web design is more than just creating a website that looks good—it’s about building an onli...

September Sunset Polo

International Polo Tour To Bridge Historic Sport, Life-Changing Philanthropy, and Breath-Taking Beau...

5 Ways Microsoft Fabric Simplifies Your Data Analytics Workflow

In today's data-driven world, businesses are constantly seeking ways to streamline their data anal...

7 Questions to Ask Before You Sign IT Support Companies in Sydney

Choosing an IT partner can feel like buying an insurance policy you hope you never need. The right c...

Choosing the Right Legal Aid Lawyer in Sutherland Shire: Key Considerations

Legal aid services play an essential role in ensuring access to justice for all. For people in t...

The Times Features

Macquarie Bank Democratises Agentic AI, Scaling Customer Innovation with Gemini Enterprise

Macquarie’s Banking and Financial Services group (Macquarie Bank), in collaboration with Google ...

Do kids really need vitamin supplements?

Walk down the health aisle of any supermarket and you’ll see shelves lined with brightly packa...

Why is it so shameful to have missing or damaged teeth?

When your teeth and gums are in good condition, you might not even notice their impact on your...

Australian travellers at risk of ATM fee rip-offs according to new data from Wise

Wise, the global technology company building the smartest way to spend and manage money internat...

Does ‘fasted’ cardio help you lose weight? Here’s the science

Every few years, the concept of fasted exercise training pops up all over social media. Faste...

How Music and Culture Are Shaping Family Road Trips in Australia

School holiday season is here, and Aussies aren’t just hitting the road - they’re following the musi...

The Role of Spinal Physiotherapy in Recovery and Long-Term Wellbeing

Back pain and spinal conditions are among the most common reasons people seek medical support, oft...

Italian Lamb Ragu Recipe: The Best Ragù di Agnello for Pasta

Ciao! It’s Friday night, and the weekend is calling for a little Italian magic. What’s better than t...

It’s OK to use paracetamol in pregnancy. Here’s what the science says about the link with autism

United States President Donald Trump has urged pregnant women[1] to avoid paracetamol except in ...