The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Times Media

.

How old’s too old to be a doctor? Why GPs and surgeons over 70 may need a health check to practise

  • Written by Christopher Rudge, Law lecturer, University of Sydney

A growing number of complaints against older doctors has prompted the Medical Board of Australia to announce[1] today that it’s reviewing how doctors aged 70 or older are regulated. Two new options are on the table.

The first would require doctors over 70 to undergo a detailed health assessment to determine their current and future “fitness to practise” in their particular area of medicine.

The second would require only general health checks for doctors over 70.

A third option acknowledges existing rules requiring doctors to maintain their health and competence. As part of their professional code of conduct[2], doctors must seek independent medical and psychological care to prevent harming themselves and their patients. So, this third option would maintain the status quo.

Haven’t we moved on from set retirement ages?

It might be surprising that stricter oversight of older doctors’ performance is proposed now. Critics of mandatory retirement ages in other fields – for judges, for instance – have long questioned whether these rules are “still valid in a modern society[3]”.

However, unlike judges, doctors are already required to renew their registration[4] annually to practise. This allows the Medical Board of Australia not only to access sound data about the prevalence and activity of older practitioners, but to assess their eligibility regularly and to conduct performance assessments[5] if and when they are needed.

What has prompted these proposals?

This latest proposal[6] identifies several emerging concerns about older doctors. These are grounded in external research about the effect of age on doctors’ competence as well as the regulator’s internal data showing surges of complaints about older doctors in recent years.

Studies of medical competence in ageing doctors show variable results[7]. However, the Medical Board of Australia’s consultation document emphasises studies of neurocognitive loss. It explains how physical and cognitive impairment can lead to poor record-keeping, improper prescribing, as well as disruptive behaviour.

The other issue is the number of patient complaints against older doctors. These “notifications” have surged in recent years, as have the number of disciplinary actions against older doctors.

In 2022–2023, the Medical Board of Australia took disciplinary action against older doctors about 1.7 times more often than for doctors under 70.

In 2023, notifications against doctors over 70 were 81% higher than for the under 70s. In that year, patients sent 485 notifications to the Medical Board of Australia about older doctors – up from 189 in 2015.

While older doctors make up only about 5.3% of the doctor workforce in Australia (less than 1% over 80), this only makes the high numbers of complaints more starkly disproportionate.

It’s for these reasons that the Medical Board of Australia has determined it should take further regulatory action to safeguard the health of patients.

So what distinguishes the two new proposed options?

The “fitness to practise” assessment option would entail a rigorous assessment of doctors over 70 based on their specialisation. It would be required every three years after the age of 70 and every year after 80.

Surgeons, for example, would be assessed by an independent occupational physician for dexterity, sight and the ability to give clinical instructions.

Importantly, the results of these assessments would usually be confidential between the assessor and the doctor. Only doctors who were found to pose a substantial risk to the public, which was not being managed, would be obliged to report their health condition to the Medical Board of Australia.

The second option would be a more general health check not linked to the doctor’s specific role. It would occur at the same intervals as the “fitness to practise” assessment. However, its purpose would be merely to promote good health-care decision-making among health practitioners. There would be no general obligation on a doctor to report the results to the Medical Board of Australia.

In practice, both of these proposals appear to allow doctors to manage their own general health confidentially.

Surgeons operating in theatre
Older surgeons could be independently assessed for dexterity, sight and the ability to give clinical instructions. worradirek/Shutterstock[8]

The law tends to prioritise patient safety

All state versions of the legal regime regulating doctors, known as the National Accreditation and Registration Scheme, include a “paramountcy” provision. That provision[9] basically says patient safety is paramount and trumps all other considerations.

As with legal regimes regulating childcare[10], health practitioner regulation prioritises the health and safety of the person receiving the care over the rights of the licensed professional.

Complicating this further, is the fact that a longstanding principle of health practitioner regulation has been that doctors should not be “punished[11]” for errors in practice.

All of this means that reforms of this nature can be difficult to introduce and that the balance between patient safety and professional entitlements must be handled with care.

Could these proposals amount to age discrimination?

It is premature to analyse the legal implications of these proposals. So it’s difficult to say how these proposals interact with Commonwealth age- and other anti-discrimination laws.

For instance, one complication is that the federal age discrimination statute includes an exemption to allow “qualifying bodies” such as the Medical Board of Australia to discriminate against older professionals who are[12] “unable to carry out the inherent requirements of the profession, trade or occupation because of his or her age”.

In broader terms, a licence to practise medicine is often compared to a licence to drive[13] or pilot an aircraft[14]. Despite claims of discrimination[15], New South Wales law requires older drivers to undergo a medical assessment every year[16]; and similar requirements affect older pilots and air traffic controllers[17].

Where to from here?

When changes are proposed to health practitioner regulation, there is typically much media attention followed by a consultation and behind-the-scenes negotiation process. This issue is no different.

How will doctors respond to the proposed changes? It’s too soon to say. If the proposals are implemented, it’s possible some older doctors might retire rather than undergo these mandatory health assessments. Some may argue that encouraging more older doctors to retire is precisely the point of these proposals. However, others have suggested[18] this would only exacerbate shortages in the health-care workforce.

The proposals are open for public comment[19] until October 4.

References

  1. ^ announce (www.medicalboard.gov.au)
  2. ^ professional code of conduct (www.medicalboard.gov.au)
  3. ^ still valid in a modern society (law.unimelb.edu.au)
  4. ^ required to renew their registration (www.medicalboard.gov.au)
  5. ^ performance assessments (www.ahpra.gov.au)
  6. ^ proposal (www.ahpra.gov.au)
  7. ^ variable results (qualitysafety.bmj.com)
  8. ^ worradirek/Shutterstock (www.shutterstock.com)
  9. ^ That provision (www8.austlii.edu.au)
  10. ^ regimes regulating childcare (legislation.nsw.gov.au)
  11. ^ punished (papers.ssrn.com)
  12. ^ who are (www8.austlii.edu.au)
  13. ^ licence to drive (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)
  14. ^ pilot an aircraft (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)
  15. ^ claims of discrimination (www.smh.com.au)
  16. ^ every year (www.nsw.gov.au)
  17. ^ pilots and air traffic controllers (www.google.com)
  18. ^ others have suggested (www1.racgp.org.au)
  19. ^ public comment (www.medicalboard.gov.au)

Read more https://theconversation.com/how-olds-too-old-to-be-a-doctor-why-gps-and-surgeons-over-70-may-need-a-health-check-to-practise-236305

The Times Features

The Budget-Friendly Traveler: How Off-Airport Car Hire Can Save You Money

When planning a trip, transportation is one of the most crucial considerations. For many, the go-to option is renting a car at the airport for convenience. But what if we told ...

Air is an overlooked source of nutrients – evidence shows we can inhale some vitamins

You know that feeling you get when you take a breath of fresh air in nature? There may be more to it than a simple lack of pollution. When we think of nutrients, we think of t...

FedEx Australia Announces Christmas Shipping Cut-Off Dates To Help Beat the Holiday Rush

With Christmas just around the corner, FedEx is advising Australian shoppers to get their presents sorted early to ensure they arrive on time for the big day. FedEx has reveale...

Will the Wage Price Index growth ease financial pressure for households?

The Wage Price Index’s quarterly increase of 0.8% has been met with mixed reactions. While Australian wages continue to increase, it was the smallest increase in two and a half...

Back-to-School Worries? 70% of Parents Fear Their Kids Aren’t Ready for Day On

Australian parents find themselves confronting a key decision: should they hold back their child on the age border for another year before starting school? Recent research from...

Democratising Property Investment: How MezFi is Opening Doors for Everyday Retail Investors

The launch of MezFi today [Friday 15th November] marks a watershed moment in Australian investment history – not just because we're introducing something entirely new, but becaus...

Times Magazine

How to Օvercome Լaziness

Everyone has moments of laziness from time to time, when all you need to do is sit or lie down and do nothing. How to overcome this laziness or stop procrastinating. Let's share some useful tips. From time to time, you can afford to be a little...

Take a Spin on a Pair of Yellow Roller Skates

History of Yellow Roller Skates Roller skates have been a popular form of transportation since the late 1700s and have seen many design changes over the years. One of the most iconic designs is that of yellow roller skates, which have become a bel...

The Power of Digital Marketing: Strategies for Success in the Digital Age

Digital marketing has emerged as a cornerstone of contemporary business strategies, revolutionizing how products and services are promoted and consumed. Since its inception in the 1990s, alongside the rapid growth of internet usage, digital marketi...

Sustainable gift ideas to help you be a conscious consumer this Christmas

With all that has happened over the past twelve months, it’s understandable that many are excited for the holiday season. However, during such times, it’s easy to lose track and either overspend or over-purchase. While the festive season is, ...

Aussie small business owner fights global Zoom fatigue with new tech

Stuck in back-to-back meetings and need the loo? A Brisbane start-up has the antidote for your work from home (WFH) woes, including a clever video loop (“On Hold”), so you can sneak away from your Zoom calls without anybody realising.  With mo...

A Guide to the Best Experience at the Monaco Grand Prix

The Monaco Grand Prix is among the jewels that Formula One or F1 owns. The high-speed chase is held in the narrow streets of Monte Carlo. And because little has changed on the race track’s exciting design since the first race was held here, the M...