The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Times Media

.

Achieving net zero with renewables or nuclear means rebuilding the hollowed-out public service after decades of cuts

  • Written by John Quiggin, Professor, School of Economics, The University of Queensland
Achieving net zero with renewables or nuclear means rebuilding the hollowed-out public service after decades of cuts

Opposition Leader Peter Dutton’s plan to build seven nuclear power plants in Australia has attracted plenty of critical attention[1]. But there’s a striking feature which has received relatively little discussion or criticism: the nuclear plants would be publicly owned and operated, similar to the National Broadband Network (NBN).

On the contrary, it received enthusiastic endorsement from free-market advocates such as The Australian’s Judith Sloan, who observed[2]: “It’s how the French nuclear plants were first constructed.” It is also the way Australia built its biggest single piece of energy infrastructure, the Snowy Mountains Scheme.

But there’s a fundamental problem here. Over the last three or four decades the federal public service has been hollowed out in the name of “new public management”. This became very clear[3] during the COVID pandemic, when state governments – who have preserved their ability to act far better – ran most of the response. There is a very real question over whether we have the governmental capacity to achieve net zero.

snowy mountains hydro scheme
The Snowy scheme took concerted effort from federal and state governments over decades. Lasse Jesper Pedersen/Shutterstock[4]

From NBN to National Nuclear Network?

Dutton’s acknowledgement[5] of the publicly owned NBN as a model worth using is a welcome advance on the view of Malcolm Turnbull, one of his predecessors as Liberal leader.

A decade ago, then-prime minister Turnbull embarked on a disastrous “mixed mode[6]” redesign of the NBN. This reflected his belief – expressed publicly after leaving office – that a publicly owned broadband network should never have existed[7].

Labor is in no position to oppose Dutton’s calls for public ownership. State Labor governments in Victoria and New South Wales have re-established publicly owned electricity enterprises, while South Australia’s Labor government has floated the same idea.

Whatever technological choices we make, it is clear our days of relying on the private sector to provide vital infrastructure are coming to an end. The question now is whether the public sector can recover to take the lead.

The National Energy Market, for instance, was meant to promote competition and drive electricity prices down. It has failed to do so[8], resulting in a string of government interventions, some more successful than others.

Arguably the biggest failed intervention was the now-defunct[9] Energy Security Board, a politically driven response to South Australia’s statewide blackout[10] in 2016.

The board sought to patch up the National Energy Market with a capacity market, which was immediately dubbed[11] “CoalKeeper” due to incentives for old coal plants to keep going, as well as new grid access charges, promptly dubbed “Solar Stopper[12]” due to discouraging new investment in solar. Energy experts did not favour[13] this approach.

What proved more successful as a response to South Australia’s big blackout was the decision by the state government to fund the Horndale big battery, which was, when built in 2017, the world’s largest utility-scale battery storage.

fiber optic internet cable outside home The publicly-owned NBN became a political football. STRINGER Image/Shutterstock[14]

Should new power be private or publicly owned?

Both major parties are flagging more intervention. The federal government has stopped waiting for markets to provide clean energy in favour of seeking tenders for new renewables through a capacity investment scheme. The scheme received 40 gigawatts[15] worth of bids from renewable developers, far beyond the goal of 6GW.

This shift has come in response to developments bogging down, hampered by inadequate regulation and local opposition driven by a combination of genuine concerns about environmental impacts and culture-war driven science denialism[16].

Labor’s current renewables-led strategy requires 10,000 kilometres[17] of new publicly built transmission lines, to meet our net zero goals. We’d need even more transmission if we are to become a major exporter of clean energy, either as electricity or in products such as green hydrogen and ammonia.

On the Coalition side, no private firm is likely to accept the risks involved in creating a nuclear power industry from scratch. Government would have to lead.

As Nationals leader David Littleproud has now acknowledged[18] in relation to finding sites for nuclear plants, the national need for clean energy is too important to allow “not in my backyard” opponents – some with only a tenuous connection[19] to the area in question – to slow or stop government plans.

If government is to lead, it must have the capacity

What Dutton’s nuclear gambit shows us is that, surprisingly, Australia’s two major political parties are in strong alignment on the need to rebuild state capacity.

Whether it’s Labor working to get transmission lines and offshore wind up and running or the Coalition working to create a nuclear industry from scratch, it will take a strong government with the capacity to articulate a plan, and the legal, financial and human resources to make it a reality.

All of these requirements were met when we constructed the Snowy Mountains Scheme, a decades-long federal government initiative undertaken in cooperation with Victoria and NSW.

Are they still in place? Not yet. Government capacity to act has been eroded over decades of neoliberalism[20]. Particularly at the national level, public service expertise has been hollowed out and replaced by reliance[21] on private consulting firms.

To rebuild the federal government’s capacity to act will require recreating the public service as a career which attracts the best and brightest graduates – many of whom currently end up in the financial sector.

The private sector still plays a central role in the construction of infrastructure, as was the case with the Snowy Scheme. But it’s up to governments to take the lead in finance and planning.

This poses particular challenges for the Liberal Party, which has long favoured the interests of businesses small and large, and has been historically opposed to public ownership. But from the late 1990s until relatively recently, Labor was also keen on privatisation.

The French Prime Minister Georges Clemenceau once observed that “war is too important to be left to generals”. As we are discovering to our cost, infrastructure investment is similarly too important to be left to private investors.

References

  1. ^ critical attention (theconversation.com)
  2. ^ who observed (www.theaustralian.com.au)
  3. ^ very clear (www.themonthly.com.au)
  4. ^ Lasse Jesper Pedersen/Shutterstock (www.shutterstock.com)
  5. ^ acknowledgement (www.thesaturdaypaper.com.au)
  6. ^ mixed mode (www.theguardian.com)
  7. ^ never have existed (www.afr.com)
  8. ^ failed to do so (theconversation.com)
  9. ^ now-defunct (www.afr.com)
  10. ^ statewide blackout (www.aer.gov.au)
  11. ^ immediately dubbed (www.crikey.com.au)
  12. ^ Solar Stopper (reneweconomy.com.au)
  13. ^ did not favour (www.theaustralian.com.au)
  14. ^ STRINGER Image/Shutterstock (www.shutterstock.com)
  15. ^ received 40 gigawatts (www.afr.com)
  16. ^ science denialism (reneweconomy.com.au)
  17. ^ 10,000 kilometres (aemo.com.au)
  18. ^ now acknowledged (www.abc.net.au)
  19. ^ tenuous connection (www.abc.net.au)
  20. ^ decades of neoliberalism (www.themonthly.com.au)
  21. ^ replaced by reliance (www.aph.gov.au)

Read more https://theconversation.com/achieving-net-zero-with-renewables-or-nuclear-means-rebuilding-the-hollowed-out-public-service-after-decades-of-cuts-233107

The Times Features

Amazon Australia and DoorDash announce two-year DashPass offer only for Prime members

New and existing Prime members in Australia can enjoy a two-year membership to DashPass for free, and gain access to AU$0 delivery fees on eligible DoorDash orders New offer co...

6 things to do if your child’s weight is beyond the ideal range – and 1 thing to avoid

One of the more significant challenges we face as parents is making sure our kids are growing at a healthy rate. To manage this, we take them for regular check-ups with our GP...

Joykids Australia Presents the Joykids Family Rave: A Weekend Adventure Like No Other

Get ready to kick off the first day of summer and the festive season with an unforgettable family adventure! Joykids Australia is excited to announce the Joykids Family Rave—an...

New study suggests weight loss drugs like Ozempic could help with knee pain. Here’s why there may be a link

The drug semaglutide, commonly known by the brand names Ozempic or Wegovy, was originally developed[1] to help people with type 2 diabetes manage their blood sugar levels. How...

Maintaining Your Pool After a Marble Interior Upgrade

After upgrading your pool with a marble interior, it’s crucial to understand that maintenance is key to preserving its elegance and longevity. You’ll want to regularly skim for d...

Labor using explanatory document to hide true powers of Misinformation Bill

The opinions and commentary of individuals could be deemed misinformation under Labor’s proposed legislation changes, according to James McComish of Victorian Bar. Appearing in...

Times Magazine

How Branded Gazebos Can Transform Your Marketing Strategy and Customer Experience

In the grand tapestry of marketing tools and strategies, branded gazebos stand out—not just literally, but metaphorically, like beacons of brand identity in a sea of sameness. While one might consider a printed marquee or custom gazebo as just a sh...

A Fantastic Look Into The Top Fitness Trackers And Swimming Apps For 2022

People want swimming pools for several reasons and the best fibreglass pools today offer myriad advantages in your backyard. Anyone who gets a pool these days wants to swim in it for fun and fitness. Once you get a pool installed, you will likely u...

The Joy of Shopping for Fabric at Your Fingertips

Benefits of Online Fabric Shopping In today's world, the internet has changed how we shop for items. Shopping online has become a popular option for many consumers and one area that is gaining traction is online fabric shopping. There are several ...

Unveiling The Future: Dive Into The Latest Canon Models Online

Canon has remained at the forefront in the rapidly changing world of photography, continually setting new standards and transforming the sector. Canon constantly introduces innovative camera models that enthrall both professionals and enthusiasts...

Some of the Main Benefits of Using Solar Panels

Solar panels are an excellent way to reduce your household energy bills and help the environment. They use the power of the sun to generate electricity for your home, which can be used for lighting, cooling, and other electrical needs. Solar panels...

Some Tips For Buying The Right Pair Of Sneakers

The old saying goes "Never judge a book by its cover". This august wisdom applies to a lot more things in life than just books, including today's topic, sneakers. It's easy to be charmed by clever designs, bright colours, and blingy glitz, but it's...