The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Times Media

.

you need more tax, working out how much more is urgent

  • Written by Michael Keating, Visiting Fellow, College of Business & Economics, Australian National University
you need more tax, working out how much more is urgent

The new government has inherited an extraordinarily difficult budget situation.

The budget deficit amounts to 3.5% of gross domestic product this financial year and it will be almost as high next financial year at 3.4%, after which the budget papers project deficits for the entire ten-year forecast period[1].

At the same time, the unemployment rate has fallen to 3.9%[2] – the lowest in five decades. It is so low it is below the 4.25% the treasury believes is needed to stop inflation accelerating[3].

In other words, the economy is operating at full capacity and inflationary pressures are mounting, with businesses complaining about difficulties in finding labour and supplies.

Households and businesses are flush with cash saved during the pandemic and prepared to spend more.

A responsible budget would immediately wind back the deficit and get to surplus within two years. Without that kind of restraint, inflationary pressures will mount and interest rates will climb higher, hurting mortgagees and crimping growth.

Labor’s budget strategy

During the election campaign, Labor’s budget strategy was built around:

  • minimising the number of its own expenditure proposals, so that next year they would add only a net A$1.1 billion[4] to the estimated $77.9 billion deficit

  • “quality” spending proposals, with Labor claiming its plan would “alleviate supply-side pressures by enhancing the productive capacity of the economy”

  • a crackdown on multinational tax avoidance and achieving substantial savings by auditing the previous government’s “rorts, waste and mismanagement”

So far, so good. But it is extremely unlikely this strategy will be sufficient to restore budget balance, and impossible for it to restore it within two years.

For one thing, even though much of Labor’s proposed spending is worthwhile, it will add to aggregate demand (spending) in the economy in the same way as would bad or wasteful spending.

Treasurer Jim Chalmers. Good as well as bad spending boosts demand. Mick Tsikas/AAP

For another, even though some of Labor’s new expenditures on things such as a better-trained workforce and cheaper child care can be expected to accelerate economic growth, they are unlikely to lift the growth rate growth rate above that underpinning the treasury forecasts in the pre-election outlook[5].

These forecasts assume that “the underlying rate of growth in labour productivity will converge over a ten-year period to the average growth rate in labour productivity over the 30 years to 2018-19 of 1.5% per annum[6]”.

But in the first six years of the Coalition government, pre-COVID, the annual rate of labour productivity growth averaged only 0.85%[7].

Furthermore, this slowdown is common to all developed economies. This means while Labor’s new programs can be expected to boost economic capacity, it is very unlikely they will lift growth above what the treasury already assumes.

Maybe an extra 4% of GDP

As important, essential services are struggling after years of under-funding.

Labor has recognised this in instances such as health, aged care, facilitating the reduction of carbon emissions, and national security, but its costings made insufficient allowance for the spending that will be required.

And more will be needed in other areas, such as higher education and research.

Overall, my rough guesstimate is that even after the savings to be had from the audit of the former government’s “rorts, waste and mismanagement”, the new government will still need to raise additional revenue equivalent to around 4% of GDP if it is to close the deficit and adequately fund essential services.

First, find out what’s needed…

Unfortunately, this extra revenue can’t be expected to come from economic growth for the reasons already given. It will have to come from raising more tax.

And that’s a problem. Australia has developed a culture where low taxation has been seen as an end in itself. For Labor to succeed, it needs to change the debate.

To this end, the new government has to quickly establish an expert committee (not a royal commission made up of lawyers) to conduct a fundamental public investigation of how much extra revenue is needed to guarantee the funding of the essential services that are underperforming and underfunded.

Read more: A new dawn over stormy seas: how Labor should manage the economy[8]

Instead of being constrained by some arbitrary taxation cap[9], the committee would develop a bottom-up estimate of how much in total is required to ensure the cost-effective provision of essential services.

In developing this bottom-up estimate, the committee would be supported by more specialist committees, such as the proposed committee to be chaired by the incoming minister for health. The eventual report would provide a carefully considered and expert assessment of how much extra spending is needed.

…then work out how to pay for it

It should also be noted that even if the extra revenue required amounted to as much as 4-5% of GDP, it would leave Australia more-lightly taxed than almost every other OECD country in Europe.

Following public consideration of that first inquiry, a second inquiry would establish how best to raise the additional revenue required. Again, the inquiry process, the evidence produced, and the final report, would be instrumental in achieving public support for the types of tax reform that were needed

These inquiries and what follows will inevitably take time – years not days.

Read more: Stand by for the oddly designed Stage 3 tax cut that will send middle earners backwards and give high earners thousands[10]

That means that some of what Labor wants to do will take time. Some will have to be part of Labor’s platform for a second term.

But the restoration of the budget balance is urgent. It could be accelerated if Labor grasped the nettle and rescinded the Stage 3 tax cuts[11] it has agreed to.

These Stage 3 cuts cost $15.7 billion in their first year (2024-25), climbing to $37 billion per year in ten years’ time. Very few taxpayers will notice, because they are directed towards the 10% of taxpayers with incomes greater than $120,000.

Small targets can’t offer big services

Labor has been fearful of debating taxation ever since the 2019 election, presenting itself as a small target.

This means it has served up a contradiction. Australians have been promised the services they need without a tax setup that will pay for them.

In 2022 Australians voted for change. Albanese and Treasurer Chalmers need to build on that and change the debate around tax. Now is the right time to start.

It needs to get Australians to understand what American jurist Oliver Wendell Holmes was getting at when he said taxes are what we pay for a civilised society[12].

References

  1. ^ entire ten-year forecast period (budget.gov.au)
  2. ^ 3.9% (theconversation.com)
  3. ^ inflation accelerating (budget.gov.au)
  4. ^ A$1.1 billion (cdn.theconversation.com)
  5. ^ pre-election outlook (theconversation.com)
  6. ^ 1.5% per annum (treasury.gov.au)
  7. ^ 0.85% (www.abs.gov.au)
  8. ^ A new dawn over stormy seas: how Labor should manage the economy (theconversation.com)
  9. ^ arbitrary taxation cap (theconversation.com)
  10. ^ Stand by for the oddly designed Stage 3 tax cut that will send middle earners backwards and give high earners thousands (theconversation.com)
  11. ^ Stage 3 tax cuts (theconversation.com)
  12. ^ for a civilised society (quoteinvestigator.com)

Read more https://theconversation.com/memo-to-labor-you-need-more-tax-working-out-how-much-more-is-urgent-183638

The Times Features

New study suggests weight loss drugs like Ozempic could help with knee pain. Here’s why there may be a link

The drug semaglutide, commonly known by the brand names Ozempic or Wegovy, was originally developed[1] to help people with type 2 diabetes manage their blood sugar levels. How...

Maintaining Your Pool After a Marble Interior Upgrade

After upgrading your pool with a marble interior, it’s crucial to understand that maintenance is key to preserving its elegance and longevity. You’ll want to regularly skim for d...

Labor using explanatory document to hide true powers of Misinformation Bill

The opinions and commentary of individuals could be deemed misinformation under Labor’s proposed legislation changes, according to James McComish of Victorian Bar. Appearing in...

Hotel Indigo launches limited-edition candle collection inspired by local neighbourhoods across ANZ

Hotel Indigo, part of IHG Hotels & Resorts' luxury and lifestyle portfolio, is releasing a limited-edition candle collection inspired by the unique neighbourhoods its hotel...

Kyndryl ANZ appoints new Head of Strategic Partnerships and Alliances

Former Head of Marketing to lead and grow Kyndryl’s local channel ecosystem and bolster technological capabilities Kyndryl has strengthened its local leadership team with the ...

Posh picnics the Sunshine Coast helicopter picnic tour

Oceanview Helicopters launches Picnic on a Peak celebrating Sunshine Coast local food and views Oceanview Helicopters has launched a new tour in preparation for the upcoming s...

Times Magazine

THE AMAZING PERKS OF PIPE RELINING IN PLUMBING

While most people know the significance of prompt pipe repairs, they also recognize how laborious and time-consuming the entire procedure can be. Digging is required during traditional repair procedures for the plumbers to access the pipelines, r...

Managing Your Online Reputation: Strategies for Removing Negative Content

Maintaining a positive online reputation is crucial for individuals and businesses in today's digital age. However, negative content such as negative reviews, defamatory posts, or outdated information can tarnish your reputation and harm your credi...

Meet the artist combating the mental impacts of advanced tech with art

In a world where advanced technology threatens to diminish our creative minds and impact our mental well-being, one extraordinary artist is taking a stand. Ange Miller, a visionary artist and advocate for the transformative power of creativity, is ...

The Key to Digital Transformation: Upgrading Your Business Systems for the Future

Digital transformation offers your business a competitive edge in today’s fast-paced market. Upgrading your systems unlocks new efficiencies, improves customer experiences, and opens doors to innovative business models. This process is not just abo...

How To Customise Your Website with HubSpot CMS: A Step-by-Step Guide

In the fast-paced digital landscape, owning a mere business website is not just enough. Your website is the first impression for your potential customer. It must be user friendly and well-designed, the content on the website needs to be appealing, ...

Understanding How a Solar Inverter Works in a Residential Solar System

As the world shifts towards sustainable energy sources, residential solar systems have become increasingly popular. At the heart of these systems is a critical component known as the solar inverter. Understanding how a solar inverter works is ess...