The Times Australia
The Times World News

.
Times Media

.

The NZ anti-vax movement’s exploitation of Holocaust imagery is part of a long and sorry history

  • Written by Giacomo Lichtner, Associate Professor of History, Te Herenga Waka — Victoria University of Wellington
The NZ anti-vax movement’s exploitation of Holocaust imagery is part of a long and sorry history

During the anti-lockdown protests[1] at parliament last year, I was told about a 15-year-old who stopped to ask someone why they were crying. The person replied they were Jewish and had been upset by Nazi imagery used by some protesters, including swastikas chalked on the ground.

Water bottle in hand, they set about washing these off, until a well-dressed, middle-aged woman threatened to kill them and parliamentary security ushered them away.

The local Jewish community sounded a warning[2] about the “grotesque and deeply hurtful” appropriation of the Holocaust by protesters that, as the situation in Wellington suggests, went unheeded.

The current occupation of parliament grounds has also seen disturbing references[3] to Nazism and the Holocaust. These have been variously deployed to call for the execution of journalists and politicians, invoke the Nuremberg Code[4] and compare vaccine mandates to the Nazi persecution of the Jews.

Not only do such comparisons rest on false equivalences, absurd leaps of logic and historical anachronism, they are also tactics that tap into long histories of exploitation of the Holocaust for political ends.

A history of appropriation

Twenty years ago, American historian Peter Novick[5] surveyed the causes (left and right) that since the 1970s had sought legitimacy and impact by comparing themselves to the Holocaust. These included:

  • anti-abortionists and pro-choice activists

  • campaigners against the death penalty

  • the National Rifle Association

  • Christian conservatives

  • LGBTQ activists during the AIDS epidemic

  • and even an Oklahoma congressman who took the TV mini-series Holocaust to be a warning of “the dangers of big government”.

Read more: In 'freedom convoy' and other vaccine protests, slogans cross the political aisle[6]

Since then, the trend has grown and the list become even more diverse. Social media and the active dissemination of conspiracy theories have made it global. Holocaust references were used to condemn both Donald Trump’s immigration laws and Barack Obama’s Affordable Care Act.

Comparisons to Nazi genocidal policies have also cropped up wherever assisted dying legislation has been debated, with opponents claiming such policies would be akin to Nazi “euthanasia”[7].

As well as being inaccurate, that argument also perpetuates the criminal Nazi deception that hid racist mass murder under the euphemism of “euthanasia”.

Anti-Nazi pastor Martin Niemöller at his first service after being released from imprisonment following the allied occupation of Germany in 1945. GettyImages

First they came for …

In this charged context, anti-Nazi pastor Martin Niemöller’s oft-cited quote[8] about apathy in the face of threat – “First they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out…” – has emerged as a favourite meme.

Niemöller had initially welcomed Hitler’s rise to power but was later incarcerated in Dachau in 1937. Visiting the camp after the war, he was struck by a sign reading: “Here in the years 1933-1945, 238,756 people were cremated.”

While his wife was shocked by the number of victims, Niemöller was horrified by the dates: where had he been between 1933 and 1937? From that experience came the famous lines lamenting German conformism and indifference that had allowed Hitler’s rise.

Read more: The Wellington protest is testing police independence and public tolerance – are there lessons from Canada’s crackdown?[9]

Niemöller never wrote them down as a poem, but would open his speeches with them, amending the groups of victims depending on his audience (as indeed do the many memorials where his words are now engraved).

The deliberate universality and adaptability of Niemöller’s words have now been hijacked by any number of protest groups, only sometimes in intended jest: “First they came for the wealthy…”, “First they came for the YouTubers…”.

Now, inevitably, the US alt-right’s “First they came for the unvaccinated…”[10] reverberates around anti-vax conference venues and the online forums of “freedom convoys”, alongside imagery featuring yellow stars and striped pyjamas.

These threaten to become the rallying cries of those with no experience of genuine dictatorships, lack of freedom or persecution, yet who share forums with neo-Nazis and anti-Semites – including in New Zealand.

A ‘Freedom and Rights Coalition’ protest at parliament on November 9 2021. GettyImages

False equivalence

Reading ourselves and our times into history is a reasonably common phenomenon and easily done. After all, what was the Nazi party in its early days other than a tiny minority of disgruntled and disaffected “ordinary” people, coalesced around economic grievances and a general sense of moral and cultural malaise?

And while some historical analogies might be wrong, they’re not always harmful. But to compare vaccine mandates to Nazism is both inaccurate and harmful. As is comparing the New Zealand government’s health response to South Africa’s apartheid regime.

Not only do such comparisons equate fundamentally different policies, they wilfully ignore the fact those historical persecutions discriminated against people for who they were, not for what they believed or how they chose to behave.

Read more: The occupation of NZ’s parliament grounds is a tactical challenge for police, but mass arrests are not an option[11]

Media and other commentators sometimes play down exploitation of the Holocaust or Nazism, either to starve it of publicity or because it can seem less serious or threatening than other more overt forms of intimidation.

But we should also guard against complacency. Since the 2019 Christchurch terror attack, New Zealand has known firsthand that racist and intolerant discourse can lead to deadly violence.

Despite evidence of violent rhetoric and behaviour in Wellington, some have sought to reassure that most protesters were “ordinary Kiwis[12]”.

Just what constitutes an “ordinary” Kiwi is open to speculation. But I’d prefer to think they’re like the compassionate teenager who took out a water bottle to help remove swastikas, not the protesters who tolerate or ignore them[13].

References

  1. ^ anti-lockdown protests (www.rnz.co.nz)
  2. ^ sounded a warning (www.newshub.co.nz)
  3. ^ disturbing references (www.rnz.co.nz)
  4. ^ Nuremberg Code (media.tghn.org)
  5. ^ Peter Novick (www.jstor.org)
  6. ^ In 'freedom convoy' and other vaccine protests, slogans cross the political aisle (theconversation.com)
  7. ^ akin to Nazi “euthanasia” (policyoptions.irpp.org)
  8. ^ oft-cited quote (encyclopedia.ushmm.org)
  9. ^ The Wellington protest is testing police independence and public tolerance – are there lessons from Canada’s crackdown? (theconversation.com)
  10. ^ “First they came for the unvaccinated…” (www.pressreader.com)
  11. ^ The occupation of NZ’s parliament grounds is a tactical challenge for police, but mass arrests are not an option (theconversation.com)
  12. ^ ordinary Kiwis (www.nzherald.co.nz)
  13. ^ tolerate or ignore them (www.newshub.co.nz)

Read more https://theconversation.com/the-nz-anti-vax-movements-exploitation-of-holocaust-imagery-is-part-of-a-long-and-sorry-history-177710

The Times Features

The Gift That Keeps Growing: Why Tinybeans+ Gift Cards are a game-changer for new parents

As new parents navigate the joys and challenges of raising a child in the digital age, one question looms large: how do you preserve and share your baby's milestones without co...

Group Adventures Made Easy: How to Coordinate Shuttle Services from DCA to IAD

Traveling as a large group can be both exciting and challenging, especially when navigating busy airports like DCA (Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport) and IAD (Washington...

From Anxiety to Assurance: Proven Strategies to Support Your Child's Emotional Health

Navigating the intricate landscape of childhood emotions can be a daunting task for any parent, especially when faced with common fears and anxieties. However, transforming anxie...

The Rise of Meal Replacement Shakes in Australia: Why The Lady Shake Is Leading the Pack

Source Meal replacement shakes are having a moment in Australia, and it’s not hard to see why. They’re quick, convenient, and packed with nutrition, making them the perfect solu...

HCF’s Healthy Hearts Roadshow Wraps Up 2024 with a Final Regional Sprint

Next week marks the final leg of the HCF Healthy Hearts Roadshow for 2024, bringing free heart health checks to some of NSW’s most vibrant regional communities. As Australia’s ...

The Budget-Friendly Traveler: How Off-Airport Car Hire Can Save You Money

When planning a trip, transportation is one of the most crucial considerations. For many, the go-to option is renting a car at the airport for convenience. But what if we told ...

Times Magazine

Business email compromise attacks are on the rise

Expert shares 5 simple steps to combat email threats every business should consider following There’s an astounding 84% increase in business email compromise attacks, according to the latest Email Threat Report, which compares half-yearly statis...

Enhance Software with Dynamic Code Analysis Techniques

Dynamic code analysis is a widely utilized technique that plays a crucial role in ensuring the reliability and security of software applications. This process involves the examination of an application's behaviour while it is executing, which is in c...

Creating a Healthier Coop with Natural Bedding

Choose the right bedding this is the first step to providing a healthy atmosphere for your hens. Natural bedding materials promote improved air quality with minimal smells, disease prevention, and more. Organically and biodegradable chicken beddi...

PIXMA and MAXIFY Inkjet printer ranges offering new features for home and business

Canon Australia today announces new models in the PIXMA and MAXIFY inkjet ranges, the PIXMA TS3660, PIXMA TS3665, PIXMA TR7860, PIXMA TS7760, MAXIFY GX1060 MegaTank, MAXIFY GX2060 MegaTank and MAXIFY GX5560 MegaTank. Canon continues to expand its...

A Fantastic Look Into The Top Fitness Trackers And Swimming Apps For 2022

People want swimming pools for several reasons and the best fibreglass pools today offer myriad advantages in your backyard. Anyone who gets a pool these days wants to swim in it for fun and fitness. Once you get a pool installed, you will likely u...

Bring Efficiency to Businesses With Cloud ERP Solutions in Singapore

What is a Cloud-based ERP Solution? Cloud-based ERP (Enterprise Resource Planning) solutions are an innovative way to manage a company's mission-critical operations. Traditional ERP systems have traditionally been on-premise, meaning they run insi...