The Times Australia
Tuesday, March 11, 2025 6:07:50 AM
Business and Money
The Times Real Estate

.

Sue me, if you can. How laws that prevent directors being sued make firms less likely to recall potentially dangerous products

  • Written by Arvid O. I. Hoffmann, Professor of Marketing, University of Adelaide
Sue me, if you can. How laws that prevent directors being sued make firms less likely to recall potentially dangerous products

About half the states in the United States have introduced so-called universal demand laws that make it harder for aggrieved shareholders to sue company directors and hold managers personally liable for decisions that have harmed the company.

One such lawsuit by Boeing shareholders resulted in current and former directors of the airline agreeing to pay it US$225 million[1] over claims they had failed to properly oversee matters related to the safety of the relatively new 737 MAX after crashes in 2018 and 2019 that killed 346 people.

The payment went to the company rather than the shareholders who sued, allowing them to benefit indirectly along with other shareholders.

Boeing is incorporated in Delaware. Had it instead been incorporated in one of the 25 or so states with “universal demand[2]” laws, the lawsuit would have been harder to get off the ground.

Universal demand laws make it harder to sue directors

In an attempt to work out the way in which the spread of these laws has changed the behaviour of directors and managers, we took advantage of their staged introduction, which began with the state of Georgia in 1989.

Our findings[3], analysing over 30 years of data from thousands of firms, were published this year in the Journal of Marketing. They point to an alarming unintended consequence of universal demand laws: a reduced willingness of firms to recall potentially hazardous products[4].

States shaded green had adopted universal demand laws by 2025. Pouyan Foroughi[5]

Firms incorporated in states that have adopted these laws are on average about 30% less likely to announce product recalls than firms incorporated in states without these rules.

We can find nothing else – neither improvements in product quality nor improvements in operational processes – that explains what we have found.

We have also observed a delay in the timing of the product recalls that firms in these states do issue.

On average, firms incorporated in states that have adopted universal demand laws wait about 50% longer before announcing recalls than firms in states that have not.

It means customers of firms incorporated in these states are exposed to potentially dangerous products for longer than customers of other firms.

In Australia and the UK too

Although our research uses data from the United States, its insights are universal.

Australia and the United Kingdom are two countries in which legal precedents[6] make it hard for shareholders to sue directors and officers of companies. This means the rules are more like those of the US states that have adopted universal demand laws than those that have not.

Our findings suggest that, by shielding Australian and UK executives from personal liability, the law in these countries makes product recalls less likely than it could be. In turn, that makes the continued use of potentially dangerous products more likely.

In the absence of effective legal sanctions in these countries and in the US states that have adopted universal demand laws, it is up to companies themselves to make it harder for their executives to cut corners.

Firms need to help themselves

Our research[7] has identified two things that can help. Both seem to have an effect in the US states that make it hard for shareholders to sue directors.

One is oversight by institutional investors. As shareholders with large financial stakes, they are motivated to monitor executives in order to protect their long-term interests in a way in which company officials might not be.

We found the effect on product recalls of being incorporated in a state with universal demand laws was 10%[8] less strong in firms with a high proportion of institutional ownership.

It’s an argument for firms to try to build up[9] the proportion of their shares owned by long-term institutional investors.

Customer advocates can make a difference

The other thing that helps is a customer-focused culture[10]. Such a culture is often denoted by the appointment of a chief marketing officer to the board of directors or the appointment of a consumer advocate.

We used text analysis of financial disclosures to develop a metric for the extent to which public companies were customer-focused.

Photo of exercise bike Late recalls hurt firms. Shutterstock[11]

We found the effect on product recalls of being in a state with universal demand laws was 11%[12] less strong in companies that were highly customer-focused.

Without a strong customer-focused culture or pressure from investors or laws that focus the minds of executives, we have found firms are more likely to take shortcuts that will hurt both their customers and their enduring reputations.

For example, in 2021 the execise equipment company Peloton finally announced a recall of its treadmills after weeks of saying there was “no reason[13]” to stop using them. Its share price fell 15.8%.

Dozens of customers had been injured and one child was reported to have died[14].

Peloton’s chief executive, John Foley, was forced to admit: “Peloton made a mistake in our initial response.” It cost it US$165 million[15] in sales.

References

  1. ^ US$225 million (www.nytimes.com)
  2. ^ universal demand (journals.sagepub.com)
  3. ^ findings (journals.sagepub.com)
  4. ^ potentially hazardous products (www.eurekalert.org)
  5. ^ Pouyan Foroughi (academic.oup.com)
  6. ^ legal precedents (classic.austlii.edu.au)
  7. ^ research (journals.sagepub.com)
  8. ^ 10% (journals.sagepub.com)
  9. ^ build up (www.mckinsey.com)
  10. ^ customer-focused culture (www.forbes.com)
  11. ^ Shutterstock (www.shutterstock.com)
  12. ^ 11% (journals.sagepub.com)
  13. ^ no reason (www.reuters.com)
  14. ^ reported to have died (www.bbc.com)
  15. ^ US$165 million (au.news.yahoo.com)

Authors: Arvid O. I. Hoffmann, Professor of Marketing, University of Adelaide

Read more https://theconversation.com/sue-me-if-you-can-how-laws-that-prevent-directors-being-sued-make-firms-less-likely-to-recall-potentially-dangerous-products-224360

SME Business News

Albanese government looking to acquire Rex Airlines if buyer can’t be found

The Albanese government will on Wednesday announce it is willing, as a last resort, to purchase the collapsed Rex Airlines, in its latest bid to prop up aviation services to regional and remo...

The Legal Battle Against IP Theft: What Businesses Need to Know

So you've formulated that million-dollar idea and you're ready to take your business to the next level. You were so excited to publicize your supposedly next big thing that you went on TikTok...

Top 20 SEO and Guest Post Services in Wyoming Helping Brands Expand Their Reach

Today’s business needs to have strong online visibility to grow and reach more customers. Guest post services and SEO services make it easier for the brand to rank higher on their search engine...

Everything You Need to Know About PLR Digital Products to Resell for Maximum Passive Income

In the ever-evolving digital product world, the concept of Private Label Rights (PLR) has emerged as a lucrative opportunity for entrepreneurs who aim to generate passive income. PLR digital prod...

The Times Features

How to Find Affordable and Quality Sheet Sets on a Budget

Finding the perfect balance between affordability and quality when shopping for sheet sets can be quite the challenge, especially if you're sticking to a budget. The right sheet se...

What’s the difference between wholemeal and wholegrain bread? Not a whole lot

If you head to the shops to buy bread, you’ll face a variety of different options. But it can be hard to work out the difference between all the types on sale. For instance...

Expert Tips for Planning Home Electrical Upgrades in Australia

Home electrical systems in Australia are quite intricate and require careful handling. Safety and efficiency determine the functionality of these systems, and it's critical to ...

Floor Tiling: Choosing the Right Tiles for Every Room

Choosing floor tiles is more than just grabbing the first design that catches your eye at the showroom. You need to think about how the floor tiling option will fit into your spa...

Exploring Family Caravans: Your Ultimate Guide to Mobile Living and Travel

Australia is the land of vast horizons, spectacular coastlines, and a never-ending adventure. As landscapes and adventures vary across the country, Voyager will route you, carava...

Energy-Efficient Homes in Geelong: How a Local Electrician Can Help You Save Money

Rising energy bills don’t have to be the new normal. With Victoria’s energy prices up 25% last year, Geelong homeowners are fighting back and winning, by partnering with licenced...

Business Times

Albanese government looking to acquire Rex Airlines if buyer can’…

The Albanese government will on Wednesday announce it is willing, as a last resort, to purchase the collapsed Rex Airline...

The Legal Battle Against IP Theft: What Businesses Need to Know

So you've formulated that million-dollar idea and you're ready to take your business to the next level. You were so excit...

Top 20 SEO and Guest Post Services in Wyoming Helping Brands Expa…

Today’s business needs to have strong online visibility to grow and reach more customers. Guest post services and SEO servi...

LayBy Shopping