The Times Australia
Business and Money
The Times Real Estate

.

What’ll happen when Facebook stops paying for news? Here’s what happened when radio stopped paying for music

  • Written by Peter Martin, Visiting Fellow, Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National University
What’ll happen when Facebook stops paying for news? Here’s what happened when radio stopped paying for music

Why are musicians so keen to get played on the radio?

It can’t be because of the money.

In Australia they are paid at rates so low they come close to making streaming services look generous. By law, no radio station can be made to pay more than 1%[1] of the station’s gross revenue for all of the music it plays, even if it is an all-music station. By the time the labels have had their cut, the artists get a lot less[2].

Legislation[3] now before the Senate would remove the ceiling, allowing radio stations and the representatives of musical artists to negotiate freely, with a final decision made by a tribunal in cases where they can’t reach agreement.

It’s a bit like the legislation set up to arbitrate disputes between platforms such as Facebook and news organisations[4] about the amount to pay for news.

The parallels tell us an awful lot about where the power lies in disputes between platforms and providers. Here’s a hint: it doesn’t lie with providers, whether they provide music, or news, or, for that matter, fruit to Coles and Woolworths.

Radio pays little for music, and always has

Here’s what happened with radio.

Legislation dating back to 1968 has given Australian radio stations a blanket right to play whatever music they want so long as they negotiate a payment rate with the relevant collecting society.

If the station and collecting society can’t agree on the rate, the decision is made by an independent tribunal[5], but, for commercial stations, the tribunal is limited to awarding no more than 1% of the station’s gross revenue, and for ABC stations, a mere half of one cent[6] per Australian resident per year.

The attorney-general introduced the ceilings to “allay the fears[7]” of radio stations and initially promised a review after five years, a provision he later dropped[8] from the final draft of the legislation. A half a century of inflation has rendered the ABC’s ceiling of half a cent per person worth a fraction of what it was.

The ABC pays half a cent per person

Triple-j logo
All of ABC radio, including triple-j, pays a total of half a cent per Australian. ABC[9]

The ceilings only apply to radio stations and only to the recordings. Television stations (including ABC stations) pay much more per track.

And composers, who are paid separately with no legislated limit, get much more.

This means the composers of You’re the Voice[10] get paid quite well, but the performer, John Farnham, does not.

The record industry has tried time and time again to remove the ceiling.

In 2010 it even went to the High Court, arguing along the lines of the case depicted in the movie The Castle[11] that the constitution prevented the Commonwealth from acquiring property other than “on just terms”.

The High Court said “no”, finding copyright wasn’t property.

Now, independent Senator David Pocock is trying again.

‘Fair pay for radio play’

Pocock’s Fair Pay for Radio Play[12] bill would remove the ceilings, allowing the radio industry and the record industry to negotiate “a fair rate[13]” subject to adjudication by the Copyright Tribunal.

The radio industry says, if that happens, it will play less Australian music[14]. It would also ask to be freed from the legislated requirement to play Australian music.

The recording industry talks as if the radio industry is bluffing.

Annabelle Herd, head of the Phonographic Performance Company of Australia, told the Senate hearing

even if the radio networks stopped playing all Australian music, they would still have to pay to play UK music, Canadian music and music from pretty much every other country in the world.

It’s a point she might not want to push too far.

In 1970 that’s exactly what happened. In response to what it felt was an over-large demand from the Phonographic Performance Company, the commercial radio industry said no, and refused to play any of its music.

Instead, it played records from independent Australian labels who didn’t charge and got their records pressed in Singapore[15], and American music, lots of it.

While the industry couldn’t play music from the UK, Canada and a bunch of other countries that were signatories to the relevant copyright treaty, it could play music from the United States, which didn’t charge, and wasn’t.

When radio called the labels’ bluff

A disc jockey quoted at the time said he didn’t think the average listener would notice[16], and there’s nothing on record to suggest the average listener did.

The Beatles album Let it Be[17] was released on May 8. The record ban[18], as it was called, came into force on May 16. The Long and Winding Road[19] cracked the top five just about everywhere it was released, apart from Australia.

Five months later, the record companies caved. The only thing the radio industry offered it was a guaranteed number of advertisements[20] per week. Which had been the radio industry’s point all along. The record companies needed ratio play for exposure. Without it, people were unlikely to buy their discs.

Read more: Facebook won't keep paying Australian media outlets for their content. Are we about to get another news ban?[21]

It’s possible to stretch parallels too far, but when Facebook temporarily stopped linking to pieces from Australian news sites in 2021, traffic to those sites slid 13%[22].

The common theme is that – as unfair as it seems – platforms have an awful lot of power over providers. If Coles and Woolworths say no, fruit growers won’t be able to distribute their product; if radio stations say no, artists won’t be as widely disseminated; and if Facebook and its ilk say no, news sites will get fewer clicks.

Facebook has been paying millions of dollars to Australian news sites since the news media bargaining code[23] began in 2021. In February it said when the agreements expire, it will pay no more[24].

The code allows the government to force Facebook to pay, but only if it continues to link to news, and it has given every indication[25] it won’t.

References

  1. ^ 1% (www5.austlii.edu.au)
  2. ^ a lot less (cdn.theconversation.com)
  3. ^ Legislation (parlinfo.aph.gov.au)
  4. ^ news organisations (www.accc.gov.au)
  5. ^ independent tribunal (www.copyrighttribunal.gov.au)
  6. ^ half of one cent (images.theconversation.com)
  7. ^ allay the fears (search.informit.org)
  8. ^ dropped (search.informit.org)
  9. ^ ABC (www.abc.net.au)
  10. ^ You’re the Voice (youtu.be)
  11. ^ The Castle (www.theguardian.com)
  12. ^ Fair Pay for Radio Play (www.aph.gov.au)
  13. ^ a fair rate (parlinfo.aph.gov.au)
  14. ^ less Australian music (parlinfo.aph.gov.au)
  15. ^ Singapore (cdn.theconversation.com)
  16. ^ notice (trove.nla.gov.au)
  17. ^ Let it Be (www.allmusic.com)
  18. ^ record ban (www.nfsa.gov.au)
  19. ^ The Long and Winding Road (www.nfsa.gov.au)
  20. ^ guaranteed number of advertisements (cdn.theconversation.com)
  21. ^ Facebook won't keep paying Australian media outlets for their content. Are we about to get another news ban? (theconversation.com)
  22. ^ 13% (www.abc.net.au)
  23. ^ news media bargaining code (www.acma.gov.au)
  24. ^ pay no more (www.abc.net.au)
  25. ^ every indication (about.fb.com)

Authors: Peter Martin, Visiting Fellow, Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National University

Read more https://theconversation.com/whatll-happen-when-facebook-stops-paying-for-news-heres-what-happened-when-radio-stopped-paying-for-music-226013

SME Business News

How Virtual Team Building Is Reshaping Modern Business Dynamics

In the past years, virtual team building has established itself as one of the cornerstones in building modern business strategy. With more organizations now switching to a model of remote or ...

How digital loyalty programs drive engagement in a value-conscious economy

Ongoing economic pressures are driving Australian retail businesses to rethink how they engage with increasingly value-conscious consumers. Rising living costs have shifted spending habits, p...

How Ofload and Logistics Tech Power Australia’s Biggest Shopping Month

Black Friday has evolved from a single day event into "Black November," overtaking December as Australia’s biggest shopping month. This shopping phenomenon, expected to drive $6.7 billion [1...

Kimberly-Clark Australia and Woolworths set to reduce plastic waste

Kimberly-Clark Australia, one of the nation’s leading personal care product manufacturers, has partnered with Woolworths on a packaging trial that’s set to remove tonnes of plastic waste from...

The Times Features

Energy-Efficient Roof Restoration Trends to Watch in Sydney

As climate consciousness rises and energy costs soar, energy-efficient roof restoration has become a significant focus in Sydney. Whether you're renovating an old roof or enhan...

Brisbane Water Bill Savings: Practical Tips to Reduce Costs

Brisbane residents have been feeling the pinch as water costs continue to climb. With increasing prices, it's no wonder many households are searching for ways to ease the burde...

Exploring Hybrid Heating Systems for Modern Homes

Consequently, energy efficiency as well as sustainability are two major considerations prevalent in the current market for homeowners and businesses alike. Hence, integrated heat...

Are Dental Implants Right for You? Here’s What to Think About

Dental implants are now among the top solutions for those seeking to replace and improve their teeth. But are dental implants suitable for you? Here you will find out more about ...

Sunglasses don’t just look good – they’re good for you too. Here’s how to choose the right pair

Australians are exposed to some of the highest levels[1] of solar ultraviolet (UV) radiation in the world. While we tend to focus on avoiding UV damage to our skin, it’s impor...

How to Style the Pantone Color of the Year 2025 - Mocha Mousse

The Pantone Color of the Year never fails to set the tone for the coming year's design, fashion, and lifestyle trends. For 2025, Pantone has unveiled “Mocha Mousse,” a rich a...

Business Times

How Virtual Team Building Is Reshaping Modern Business Dynamics

In the past years, virtual team building has established itself as one of the cornerstones in building modern business st...

How digital loyalty programs drive engagement in a value-consciou…

Ongoing economic pressures are driving Australian retail businesses to rethink how they engage with increasingly value-co...

How Ofload and Logistics Tech Power Australia’s Biggest Shopping …

Black Friday has evolved from a single day event into "Black November," overtaking December as Australia’s biggest shoppi...

LayBy Shopping