The Times Australia
The Times Australia

.
The Times Real Estate

.

Australia desperately needs a strong federal environmental protection agency. Our chances aren’t looking good

  • Written by Justine Bell-James, Associate Professor in Environment and Property Law, TC Beirne School of Law, The University of Queensland

When Labor came to power federally after almost a decade in opposition, Environment Minister Tanya Plibersek pledged[1] to turn around Australia’s worsening environmental woes, from extinctions to land clearing to climate change.

While the government has made progress on climate action[2], protecting biodiversity hasn’t got out of the starting blocks.

In the latest example of inaction, proposed laws to create an independent environmental regulator, Environmental Protection Australia, appear stalled in the Senate. Labor needs the backing of the Coalition or the Greens to push the reform through. At the time of writing, no deals looked likely.

This is a real problem. A stream of audits and reviews have shown Australia’s environmental laws are not fit for purpose. Change is possible – but hard. Keeping the status quo is far easier, no matter how dysfunctional it is.

bulldozer dirt new suburb
Development proposals assessed under the EPBC Act are nearly always approved. Deek/Shutterstock[3]

Pushback in and out of parliament

The latest impasse stems from efforts to overhaul Australia’s ageing and feeble national environment laws, the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation (EPBC) Act[4].

The failings of the law are no secret. In 2020, an independent review by Graeme Samuel delivered blunt findings[5]: the laws were simply not protecting nature.

Labor drafted stronger laws, but developers and miners quickly pushed back[6].

So Labor changed tack. It pivoted to a staged reform process – with the full-scale revamp delayed indefinitely.

This week, Labor attempted to pass at least some change – a bill to create an independent environmental regulator, Environmental Protection Australia. But it ran into major roadblocks.

Mining companies such as Gina Rinehart’s Hancock Prospecting and Rio Tinto pushed for the regulator to be stripped of its powers[7] in a private letter to Prime Minister Anthony Albanese.

And Coalition and Greens senators delivered stinging critiques[8], arguing variously that the regulator would be too strong or too weak.

Crossbenchers and the Greens say to win their support, Labor must end native forest logging nationally and require consideration of climate damage when assessing projects such as new coal mines for approvals.

How did we get into this mess?

In 2000, the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act[9] came into force, superseding a patchwork of previous laws.

The laws focused on threatened species and ecosystems but did not mention damage done by climate change.

Almost a quarter of a century later, we still have the same set of laws, described as ineffective or little enforced in audits[10] and reviews[11].

Every year since the act came into force, Austalia’s threatened species populations have actually fallen 2-3%[12].

When development, agriculture and infrastructure projects do get assessed under these laws, about 99%[13] are approved.

Experts have found the laws permit ongoing destruction[14] of critical habitat for threatened species.

Why? While the environment minister of the day is required to consider environmental impacts of a proposal, they can essentially rule any way they like[15] – even if it goes against the opinion of independent environmental experts, or their own bureaucrats.

Why is change so hard?

The 2020 Samuel review recommended new “national environmental standards” be enforced. These would mean explicitly defining what outcomes for nature we are aiming for, and making sure a development proposal met that standard.

For example, one proposed standard[16] would disallow “unacceptable or unsustainable impacts” on matters of national environmental significance. These matters include[17] internationally important wetlands and nationally threatened species. Other standards include preservation of Australia’s natural world heritage sites, such as the Great Barrier Reef.

In late 2022, Plibersek released Labor’s official response in the form of the Nature Positive Plan[18].

The plan seemed promising. It recognised the dire state of Australia’s species and ecosystems and labelled the current laws “ineffective”. It promised national environmental standards.

woman holding baby tassie devil Environment minister Tanya Plibersek holds a baby Tasmanian devil on Threatened Species Day last week. Mick Tsikas/AAP[19]

Plibersek vowed to consult on further changes. This led to a proposal[20] to replace the EPBC Act with stronger laws, and create a new regulator – Environment Protection Australia.

As initiailly proposed, this independent agency would have power to make development decisions and ensure compliance. It would only grant approval to a project if it was consistent with national environmental standards. The minister could still step in, but had to give public reasons for doing so, and take advice from the regulator.

However, major lobby groups opposed[21] the proposed overhaul of the laws.

In response, Plibersek changed tactics. She announced environmental reform would be in three stages[22].

The first was the Nature Repair Market[23], which passed Parliament late last year. The second stage involved the laws now before the Senate: creating Environment Protection Australia in a weaker form (without the restrictions on discretion in the initial proposal) and a data and monitoring agency, Environment Information Australia.

If passed, these bills would create a protection agency – but one which could only enforce the same weak approval laws and be subject to the same broad discretion for the decision-maker. For the agency to have teeth, the government would need to pass stage three, which would reduce discretion, introduce stronger environment laws and create legally binding National Environmental Standards.

Unfortunately, Labor has now deferred these indefinitely[24].

Stalled at stage two

The government is clearly struggling to pass its stage two reforms.

Conservationists are increasingly worried[25] by the delays, while Western Australia’s mining companies have come out strongly[26] against the EPA.

This is a problem for Labor. Western Australia was instrumental in the party’s election win in 2022 and it needs to shore up seats in the mining-heavy state[27] ahead of the next federal election.

Meanwhile, Opposition Leader Peter Dutton has pledged to be the mining sector’s best friend[28] if elected, by cutting “green tape”, fast tracking resource projects and defunding the Environmental Defenders Office.

And the Greens are showing little sign[29] of compromise on their demands.

All this is bad news for our threatened species and sick ecosystems. We know what needs to be done. But our government is showing worrying signs of letting industry and developers control their environmental agenda.

References

  1. ^ pledged (minister.dcceew.gov.au)
  2. ^ progress on climate action (www.aph.gov.au)
  3. ^ Deek/Shutterstock (www.shutterstock.com)
  4. ^ Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation (EPBC) Act (www.dcceew.gov.au)
  5. ^ delivered blunt findings (www.dcceew.gov.au)
  6. ^ quickly pushed back (www.afr.com)
  7. ^ stripped of its powers (www.miningday.com.au)
  8. ^ stinging critiques (www.aph.gov.au)
  9. ^ Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act (www.dcceew.gov.au)
  10. ^ audits (www.anao.gov.au)
  11. ^ reviews (www.dcceew.gov.au)
  12. ^ fallen 2-3% (theconversation.com)
  13. ^ about 99% (www.dcceew.gov.au)
  14. ^ ongoing destruction (theconversation.com)
  15. ^ any way they like (theconversation.com)
  16. ^ proposed standard (www.dcceew.gov.au)
  17. ^ matters include (www.dcceew.gov.au)
  18. ^ Nature Positive Plan (www.dcceew.gov.au)
  19. ^ Mick Tsikas/AAP (photos.aap.com.au)
  20. ^ proposal (consult.dcceew.gov.au)
  21. ^ opposed (theconversation.com)
  22. ^ three stages (www.abc.net.au)
  23. ^ Nature Repair Market (www.dcceew.gov.au)
  24. ^ deferred these indefinitely (theconversation.com)
  25. ^ are increasingly worried (www.acf.org.au)
  26. ^ come out strongly (www.miningday.com.au)
  27. ^ shore up seats in the mining-heavy state (www.theaustralian.com.au)
  28. ^ mining sector’s best friend (www.theguardian.com)
  29. ^ showing little sign (www.abc.net.au)

Read more https://theconversation.com/australia-desperately-needs-a-strong-federal-environmental-protection-agency-our-chances-arent-looking-good-239099

Newspoll returns to a tie after Coalition leads, but Labor has worst result this term in Resolve

A national Newspoll[1], conducted December 2–6 from a sample of 1,258, had a 50–50 tie, a one-point gain for Lab...

The Times Features

Fast, Fun, And Fantastic Looking Gel Polish For Your Nails!

Today's women spend a lot of time and money on their beauty and fashion regime because they love looking their very best! Looking good makes you feel good, and let's face it, it...

Energy-Efficient Roof Restoration Trends to Watch in Sydney

As climate consciousness rises and energy costs soar, energy-efficient roof restoration has become a significant focus in Sydney. Whether you're renovating an old roof or enhan...

Brisbane Water Bill Savings: Practical Tips to Reduce Costs

Brisbane residents have been feeling the pinch as water costs continue to climb. With increasing prices, it's no wonder many households are searching for ways to ease the burde...

Exploring Hybrid Heating Systems for Modern Homes

Consequently, energy efficiency as well as sustainability are two major considerations prevalent in the current market for homeowners and businesses alike. Hence, integrated heat...

Are Dental Implants Right for You? Here’s What to Think About

Dental implants are now among the top solutions for those seeking to replace and improve their teeth. But are dental implants suitable for you? Here you will find out more about ...

Sunglasses don’t just look good – they’re good for you too. Here’s how to choose the right pair

Australians are exposed to some of the highest levels[1] of solar ultraviolet (UV) radiation in the world. While we tend to focus on avoiding UV damage to our skin, it’s impor...

Times Magazine

In-Depth Guides to Mobility Scooters

Electric scooters play a very important role in the daily needs of many people. They are ideal for the elderly, injured, and disabled who want to regain their independence when it comes to going from one place to another. Learn about the history ...

Prevent Electrical Hazards With Key Safety Measures for Power Strip Circuit Breaker

As the reliance on technology increases, so does the number of electronic devices use on a daily basis. With this increase in electronic usage, the need for power strips has become more prevalent. Power strips are used as a convenient way to increa...

Racer Holly Espray hits the track with Uniden for V8 SuperUte Series in Bathurst

Leading SuperUte racer Holly Espray is geared up for her next big challenge at Bathurst, and she's relying on support from her new sponsor Uniden, known for its cutting-edge technology, to keep her connected and secure, both on and off the track. ...

Faultless Journeys: Exploring the Benefits of Bus Charter Services in Brisbane

Brisbane is a city full of lights, diversity, change and colours. It is populated with cultural differences and multiple businesses that offer a bundle of opportunities for interaction. There are multiple places to visit and explore in cases wher...

Understanding Hair Loss in Men: Causes, Prevention, and Effective Care Routines

Most men suffer from hair loss, which is a common problem affecting millions of users worldwide and starts at various stages — Some may even have their hair thinning in the early 20s While others cannot observe any signs later on. No matter how it ...

The Ultimate Guide to Concrete Scanning in Australia

The metropolitan area of Brisbane is all in for edifice and expansion projects. The safety, accuracy and protection of architectural buildings is also important. One aspect is to do concrete scanning and this is non-destructive testing. The real ...

LayBy Shopping