The Times Australia
Business and Money
The Times Real Estate

.

Taking China to the World Trade Organisation plants a seed. It won't be a quick or easy win

  • Written by Weihuan Zhou, Senior Lecturer and member of Herbert Smith Freehills CIBEL Centre, Faculty of Law, UNSW Sydney, UNSW

Australia is reportedly ready[1] to initiate its first litigation against China at the World Trade Organisation.

China has this year taken punitive action[2] against imports of Australian coal, wine, beef, lobster and barley.

It is the five-year 80.5% barley tariff China imposed in May that Australia will take to the World Trade Organisation. More than half of all Australian barley exports in 2019 were sold to China, worth about A$600 million a year to Australian farmers.

Taking China to the World Trade Organisation plants a seed. It won't be a quick or easy win CC BY[3] Chinese authorities began an anti-dumping investigation into Australian barley in November 2018[4]. Anti-dumping trade rules are meant to protect local producers from unfair competition from “dumped” imported goods. Dumping occurs where a firm sells goods in an overseas market at a price lower than the normal value of the goods. China calculated the normal value of barley using “best information available” on the grounds that Australian producers and exporters failed to provide all information Chinese investigators requested. The barley tariff will last for five years unless Chinese investigators initiate a review and decide to extend it beyond 2025. What can Australia hope to achieve from a WTO dispute? Not a quick and easy win. A formal resolution will likely take years. But it plants a seed, starting a structured process for dialogue. This is an important step in the right direction. Read more: Barley is not a random choice – here's the real reason China is taking on Australia over dumping[5] A lengthy process WTO litigation is no quick fix. There is a set process that moves through three phases – consultation, adjudication and compliance. The standard timetable would ideally have disputes move through consultation and adjudication within a year. In reality it often take several years, particularly if appeals or compliance actions are involved. The timetable schedules 60 days for the first stage of negotiations, though these can take many more months. That’s worthwhile if it leads to a resolution. But given the tensions between China and Australia, a quick resolution looks remote. The adjudication process typically involves a decision by a WTO panel followed by an appeal to the organisation’s Appellate Body. A WTO panel is meant to issue its decision within nine months of its establishment, but it usually takes much more time. If the panel’s decision is appealed, the Appellate Body is meant to make its decisions within 90 days, but nor is this time frame met in many cases. Once a WTO decision is final, it is up to the losing party to comply with the ruling. That may include a request for time to make the necessary changes. In practice, this can take six to 15 months[6]. Barley crop China’s tariff on Australian barley comprises an ‘anti-dumping duty’ of 73.6% and a ‘countervailing duty’ of 6.9%. Ted S. Warren/AP Read more: An all-out trade war with China would cost Australia 6% of GDP[7] Appeals blockage One complication is the current non-functioning WTO appeals process. Appointing judges to the WTO’s Appellate Body requires agreement from all WTO member nations. US obstruction[8] of new appointments has reduced the number of judges to zero, and the Appellate Body requires three judges to hear appeals. This paralysis has created a major loophole, enabling an “appeal into the void” to block unfavourable rulings. In light of this, the 27 European Union nations and 22 other WTO members – including both China and Australia – have signed on to a temporary appeals process known as the “multi-party interim appeal arbitration arrangement[9]” (MPIA). Given China’s commitment[10] to the WTO and its dispute settlement system, there is no reason to anticipate it snubbing interim arrangements if an appeal arises. But the appeal process is also likely to take just as long as the Appellate Body procedure. No guaranteed win Federal Trade Minister Simon Birmingham has expressed confidence in Australia’s “strong case[11]” but victory against China is not assured. China’s tariff on Australian barley comprises an “anti-dumping duty[12]” of 73.6% and a “countervailing duty[13]” of 6.9%. Anti-dumping and countervailing calculations are highly technical. Whether China’s barley tariff has violated WTO rules will require detailed examination of its methodology. A key challenge to the Chinese methodology is that it largely disregarded information on domestic sales by Australian barley producers and used data from Australian sales to Egypt. The WTO has found China’s use of similar methods in several past disputes[14] breached WTO rules. But every case depends on very specific facts. The past rulings against China do not necessarily predict the result here. Read more: Why China believed it had a case to hit Australian barley with tariffs[15] No compensation Even if Australia is successful, a “win” isn’t total. The WTO system is designed to make states change their ways. It is not designed to compensate those harmed by illegal trade measures. In other words, an Australian win may require China only to remove the tariff, not compensate those who paid more or lost revenue as a result. There is also a risk that China could simply initiate a re-investigation of the barley tariff, which might lead to a decision to impose duties very similar to the original ones. In some past disputes, it took China five years or longer[16] to remove duties. So even if the World Trade Organisation rules in favour of Australia, this might not lead to the tariff’s end before its current expiry date in 2025. Still the best option Despite all this, the World Trade Organisation is Australia’s best step. The WTO is not perfect, but it is now a tested and respected mechanism to resolve trade disputes. WTO litigation also compels the disputing parties to enter into consultations – and talking is something Australia’s officials have had difficulty having with their Chinese counterparts. China might drag its heels in other ways, but it can be expected to respect the WTO’s procedural rules and enter into these negotiations. Those talks could help repair communication channels better than missives through social media and press conferences. Taking China to the World Trade Organisation plants a seed. It won't be a quick or easy win Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson Zhao Lijian, at a briefing in Beijing on November 17, says Australia should do something ‘to promote mutual trust and co-operation’ in response to Australian Trade Minister Simon Birmingham calling for dialogue and discussion. AP Litigation the new normal In commencing a formal dispute, Australia also sends a firm but dignified message – that it is willing to use international rules and procedures to solve grievances. WTO litigation is a normal feature of trade relations between countries. Even close allies bring disputes against one another – such as New Zealand’s case against Australia’s restrictions[17] on New Zealand apples, or Australia’s case against Canadian restrictions [18] on imported wines in liquor stores. China and Australia badly need a relationship reset[19]. Meeting in a rules-based forum with structured processes for dialogue can do no harm.

References

  1. ^ reportedly ready (www.abc.net.au)
  2. ^ taken punitive action (www.scmp.com)
  3. ^ CC BY (creativecommons.org)
  4. ^ November 2018 (theconversation.com)
  5. ^ Barley is not a random choice – here's the real reason China is taking on Australia over dumping (theconversation.com)
  6. ^ take six to 15 months (www.worldtradelaw.net)
  7. ^ An all-out trade war with China would cost Australia 6% of GDP (theconversation.com)
  8. ^ US obstruction (www.eastasiaforum.org)
  9. ^ multi-party interim appeal arbitration arrangement (trade.ec.europa.eu)
  10. ^ commitment (english.www.gov.cn)
  11. ^ strong case (www.smh.com.au)
  12. ^ anti-dumping duty (trb.mofcom.gov.cn)
  13. ^ countervailing duty (trb.mofcom.gov.cn)
  14. ^ disputes (www.bloomsburyprofessional.com)
  15. ^ Why China believed it had a case to hit Australian barley with tariffs (theconversation.com)
  16. ^ five years or longer (www.bloomsburyprofessional.com)
  17. ^ case against Australia’s restrictions (www.wto.org)
  18. ^ against Canadian restrictions (www.wto.org)
  19. ^ relationship reset (theconversation.com)

Authors: Weihuan Zhou, Senior Lecturer and member of Herbert Smith Freehills CIBEL Centre, Faculty of Law, UNSW Sydney, UNSW

Read more https://theconversation.com/taking-china-to-the-world-trade-organisation-plants-a-seed-it-wont-be-a-quick-or-easy-win-152173

SME Business News

Albanese government looking to acquire Rex Airlines if buyer can’t be found

The Albanese government will on Wednesday announce it is willing, as a last resort, to purchase the collapsed Rex Airlines, in its latest bid to prop up aviation services to regional and remo...

The Legal Battle Against IP Theft: What Businesses Need to Know

So you've formulated that million-dollar idea and you're ready to take your business to the next level. You were so excited to publicize your supposedly next big thing that you went on TikTok...

Top 20 SEO and Guest Post Services in Wyoming Helping Brands Expand Their Reach

Today’s business needs to have strong online visibility to grow and reach more customers. Guest post services and SEO services make it easier for the brand to rank higher on their search engine...

Everything You Need to Know About PLR Digital Products to Resell for Maximum Passive Income

In the ever-evolving digital product world, the concept of Private Label Rights (PLR) has emerged as a lucrative opportunity for entrepreneurs who aim to generate passive income. PLR digital prod...

The Times Features

What’s the difference between wholemeal and wholegrain bread? Not a whole lot

If you head to the shops to buy bread, you’ll face a variety of different options. But it can be hard to work out the difference between all the types on sale. For instance...

Expert Tips for Planning Home Electrical Upgrades in Australia

Home electrical systems in Australia are quite intricate and require careful handling. Safety and efficiency determine the functionality of these systems, and it's critical to ...

Floor Tiling: Choosing the Right Tiles for Every Room

Choosing floor tiles is more than just grabbing the first design that catches your eye at the showroom. You need to think about how the floor tiling option will fit into your spa...

Exploring Family Caravans: Your Ultimate Guide to Mobile Living and Travel

Australia is the land of vast horizons, spectacular coastlines, and a never-ending adventure. As landscapes and adventures vary across the country, Voyager will route you, carava...

Energy-Efficient Homes in Geelong: How a Local Electrician Can Help You Save Money

Rising energy bills don’t have to be the new normal. With Victoria’s energy prices up 25% last year, Geelong homeowners are fighting back and winning, by partnering with licenced...

Eating disorders don’t just affect teen girls. The risk may go up around pregnancy and menopause too

Eating disorders impact more than 1.1 million people in Australia[1], representing 4.5% of the population. These disorders include binge eating disorder, bulimia nervosa, and...

Business Times

Albanese government looking to acquire Rex Airlines if buyer can’…

The Albanese government will on Wednesday announce it is willing, as a last resort, to purchase the collapsed Rex Airline...

The Legal Battle Against IP Theft: What Businesses Need to Know

So you've formulated that million-dollar idea and you're ready to take your business to the next level. You were so excit...

Top 20 SEO and Guest Post Services in Wyoming Helping Brands Expa…

Today’s business needs to have strong online visibility to grow and reach more customers. Guest post services and SEO servi...

LayBy Shopping